The Three Men Who Sent Jesus to the Cross_ and What Became of Each of Them (No Ads))

Welcome back to the Bible Stories. You may notice there

are no ads on this video because YouTube has demonetized

our channel. To support us, you can scan the first

QR code to join the Bible Stories podcast app, where

you can listen offline and access exclusive episodes. Or, if

you simply want to give, you can scan the second

QR code to donate directly. Thank you for helping us

keep these Bible Stories going. Three men decided that Jesus

of Nazareth would die, Caiaphas the high priest, who held

the temple, Herod Antipas, who held Galilee, and Pontius Pilate,

the Roman governor, who held the only signature that could

legally end a life. Between the middle of the night

and the middle of the following morning, all three of

them had him in their hands, questioned him, and passed

him along. Ask most Christians what became of those three afterward,

and the answer comes back in one of two shapes.

Either God struck them down in some terrible way that

nobody could miss, or the Bible says nothing at all

and they died old and comfortable. Both answers are wrong.

Nothing supernatural happened to any of them. There was no lightning,

no plague, no earthquake aimed at a house. Each of

the three simply kept doing the exact thing that had

kept him in power for years, and that is what

destroyed him. Within about four years of that morning, all

three had lost their positions, and in every case the

hand that took it away was Rome, the same Rome

each of them had leaned on to stay safe. So

this is not a story about God settling a score.

It is a story about what happens to a man

who builds his life on protecting himself. And if you

have ever watched someone cause real damage and walk away

with the job, the house, the reputation, and the years

all intact, while you prayed and the sky stayed closed,

then you already know why these three are worth an

hour of your attention. They had more power than anyone

who ever hurt you. Watch where every bit of it went.

One of them has an ending the Bible itself reports,

and it is the one nobody sees coming. A few

years after the crucifixion, he was made to face the

same question a second time, in the same chamber, with

the same council seated around him, and the answer came

back to him from the mouths of men he had

already seen, standing in his own courtyard, on the night

it all began. The arrest happened at night, in an

olive grove outside the city walls, and the timing was deliberate.

Jerusalem was packed for Passover. The city normally held tens

of thousands of people, and during the feast it swelled

with pilgrims from every direction. Arresting a popular teacher in

daylight in front of that crowd risked exactly the kind

of disorder that Rome punished by removing whoever had let

it happen. So they came in the dark with lamps

and weapons, and they bound him. What is easy to

miss is that the decision had already been made months

before in a meeting Jesus was not present for. After

Lazarus came out of the tomb, the council gathered to

talk about the problem, and it was Caiaphas who ended

the debate. You do not realize that it is better

for you that one man die for the people than

that the whole nation perish. John 11.50 That sentence is

the whole trial in advance. Everything that happened on the

night of the arrest was procedure arranged around a verdict

that already existed. Jesus was not taken to Caiaphas first.

He was taken to a private house belonging to Annas,

the father-in-law of Caiaphas, a former high priest who had

been removed by Rome years earlier and had never really

let go. Annas had been high priest, and after him

the office went to five of his sons and to Caiaphas,

who had married his daughter. The most sacred office in

Israel had become a family holding. The man who examined

Jesus first had no legal standing at all. He simply

still had the room. Count the movements and the speed

of the thing becomes clear. He was taken to the

house of Annas, then to the house of Caiaphas in

the dark, then back before the full council at first light,

so that the night decision would look official, then to

the governor, then across the city to Herod, then back

to the governor a second time. Six stops, and all

of it finished before the middle of the morning. Cases

involving a man's life were supposed to take days, with

the verdict delayed to a second sitting, so that anyone

with doubts had a night to think. This one was

closed before most of Jerusalem had eaten breakfast. From there,

Jesus was moved to the house of Caiaphas, where the

council had gathered in the middle of the night, which

was itself irregular. Witnesses were brought in, and their statements

did not line up. The case was falling apart in

front of them, and then the high priest stood up

and asked one question that changed everything. He had tried accusations,

and they had failed. So Caiaphas put it directly, and

he asked the one thing that could not be answered safely.

Are you the Messiah, the Son of the Blessed One?

Jesus had spent three years deflecting that question. He told

people who were healed to say nothing. He withdrew when

crowds wanted to make him king. He answered in stories

and let people work it out slowly. Now, bound in

a night court with men waiting for a reason to

kill him, he answered plainly, I am, said Jesus, and

you will see the Son of Man sitting at the

right hand of the Mighty One and coming on the

clouds of heaven. Mark 14.62 That is the clearest statement

about himself that Jesus ever made in public, and he

made it to the man most determined to destroy him.

He did not soften it or leave room for a

second reading. He took a phrase every man in that

room knew from the book of Daniel, a vision of

a figure who comes with the clouds and receives an

everlasting kingdom, and he applied it to himself while standing

in chains. The high priest tore his clothes. Under the

law of Moses, the high priest was forbidden to tear

his garments, as Leviticus chapter 21 verse 10 states plainly.

Leviticus 21:10

The man responsible for guarding the holy things broke that

instruction in the act of defending them. It is the

picture of the whole night in one gesture. Everything about

that trial was done in the name of protecting God,

and every step of it was outside the law they

claimed to protect. Understand what Caiaphas was actually protecting. He

had held the high priesthood for about eighteen years, which

in that period was almost unheard of. Rome appointed high

priests and removed them at will, and most of them

lasted a year or two. Caiaphas lasted through four Roman governors.

He was not a reckless man. He was a survivor

with an extraordinary sense of what Rome would tolerate, and

he had built his entire life on keeping the temple

system standing by giving Rome no reason to interfere. Then

a teacher from Galilee walked into the temple courts and

turned over the tables of the men who exchanged money there.

That act is usually preached as a story about reverence,

and it is. It was also an attack on income.

Pilgrims arriving for a feast needed animals that had passed

inspection and coins that were acceptable inside the courts, and

the men supplying both were operating inside the high priest's territory,

under his family's authority, with a share of what changed hands.

When Jesus drove them out, he was not making a

general point about greed in the abstract. He was interrupting

the household finances of the man who would later stand

up in the middle of the night and ask him

whether he was the son of the Blessed One. For Caiaphas,

none of this was a religious dispute. It was a

threat to the arrangement that kept him alive. By dawn,

Jesus was standing in front of Pilate, and Pilate did

not want him. When the governor heard the word Galilee,

he saw a way out. Galilee belonged to Herod Antipas,

and Antipas happened to be in Jerusalem for the feast.

So Pilate sent the prisoner across the city to another

man's jurisdiction and hoped the problem would stay there. Herod

Antipas was a son of Herod the Great, the king

who had ordered the killing of the children in Bethlehem.

Antipas had ruled Galilee and the region east of the

Jordan for more than thirty years by then, longer than

any other member of his family managed. He had built

a city on the shore of the lake and named

it Tiberius to flatter the emperor. He was not a king,

though he wanted the title badly. Rome had given him

the lesser rank. of Tetrarch, and the difference gnawed at

him for his entire life. He also had a history

with prophets. John the Baptist had told him publicly that

his marriage to Herodias, the former wife of his own brother,

was unlawful. Antipas arrested him, He kept him alive for

a while because he liked listening to him. And then,

at a birthday feast in front of guests, he gave

an order he could not take back, and John was

executed in a cell. When reports about Jesus started reaching

his court, Antipas became uneasy. He had heard about the

healings and the crowds, and something in him connected the

new teacher to the man he had killed— At one

point he made threats, and Jesus sent back a reply

that was not the least bit frightened. Go tell that fox,

I will keep on driving out demons and healing people

today and tomorrow, and on the third day I will

reach my goal. Luke chapter 13 verse 32 So on

Luke 13:32

the morning of the trial, Antipas finally got what he

had wanted for years. The prisoner was delivered to his door.

He was delighted. He had been hoping for a long

time to see this man do something remarkable, and now

the man was standing in his hall with soldiers on

either side and no way to leave. He asked question

after question. He plied him with many questions, but Jesus

gave him no answer. Luke chapter 23 verse 9. Take

Luke 23:9

that in. Jesus spoke to Pharisees who came to trap him.

He spoke to a thief on a cross. He answered

Caiaphas who wanted him dead, and he would shortly hold

a long conversation with Pilate about kingdoms and truth. Herod

Antipas is the only person in all four Gospels who

asked Jesus a direct question and received nothing at all,

not a rebuke, not a parable, not a word. The

silence was the verdict. Antipas had already been given a

prophet for months at close range with every chance to listen,

and it had ended with an execution to save face

at a party. A man who had already refused the

answer was given no new one. He handled the silence

the way men in power usually handle being ignored. He

and his soldiers made a joke of the prisoner, dressed

him in a fine robe, and sent him back across

the city. Luke adds one line about that day that

is easy to read past. That day, Herod and Pilate

became friends. The two of them had been enemies before this.

Two rulers who could not stand each other found common

ground in the handling of Jesus of Nazareth, and the

friendship cost each of them nothing except a man neither

of them wanted to deal with. Pontius Pilate had been

governor of Judea for about ten years by that Passover,

and his record was not good. He lived in Caesarea

on the coast and came up to Jerusalem with troops

for the major feasts, when the crowds were largest and

the risk of trouble was highest. Early in his term

he sent soldiers into Jerusalem carrying military standards bearing the

emperor's image, which the population regarded as an offense against God.

A crowd traveled to Caesarea and lay in the open

for five days, refusing to move until he took them down. Later,

he took money from the temple treasury to build an

aqueduct into the city. When protests broke out over that,

he had soldiers in plain clothes mixed into the crowd,

and people were killed. So when the chief priests told

him that releasing this prisoner would make him no friend

of Caesar, Pilate understood the sentence exactly. Another complaint to Rome,

especially one that reached the emperor Tiberius, could finish him.

That is the pressure he was under. And still, three

separate times, he said out loud that he could find

no basis for a charge against the man. He tried

to release him under a Passover custom, and the crowd

asked for a rebel named Barabbas instead. He had him flogged,

probably hoping that would satisfy them. He sent him to Herod.

He came back to the question again and again, like

a man looking for a door. At one point, his

wife sent word to him while he was actually seated

on the judge's bench, telling him to have nothing to

do with that innocent man because of a dream she

had suffered through. He went ahead, anyway. Between them, in

the middle of the trial, there is a short exchange

that has echoed for two thousand years. Jesus said he

had come into the world to testify to the truth,

and that everyone on the side of truth listens to him.

Pilate answered with three words,' What is truth?' John, chapter 18,

John 18:38

verse 38. He did not wait for a reply. He

walked back outside to manage the crowd. That is the

tragedy of Pilate in one movement. He was closer to

the answer than any philosopher in the empire. He asked

the right question, and then he left the room because

there was a political situation to handle. Truth was standing

in front of him bleeding, and he had a schedule.

Later in the morning, with the prisoner standing in front

of him refusing to speak, Pilate reached for the only

argument a Roman governor had left. Do you not realize

I have power either to free you or to crucify you?

The answer he got should have ended the trial. You

would have no power over me if it were not

given to you from above. John chapter 19 verse 11

John 19:11

Hold that sentence next to everything you have heard so far,

because it explains the endings of all three men. Pilate

believed the authority in that room was his. Caiaphas believed

the temple system was his to protect. Antipas believed a

crown was something a man could ask for and receive.

And the prisoner, bleeding and condemned, told the most powerful

of them where authority actually comes from and who is

allowed to lend it out. Every one of the three

was holding something borrowed, and none of them knew it.

In the end, Pilate called for water and washed his

hands where everyone could see it.' I am innocent of

this man's blood,' he said.' It is your responsibility.' Matthew,

Matthew 27:24

chapter 27, verse 24. It was a ceremony, and it

was meaningless. He was the only man in Judea with

the authority to stop the execution, and he used that

authority to order it. Washing your hands does not transfer

a decision to somebody else. It only tells everyone watching

that you know exactly what you are about to do.

Start with Caiaphas, because his ending is the one the

Bible itself reports. A few years after the crucifixion, two

fishermen were arrested in Jerusalem for healing a man at

the temple gate and preaching in the name of Jesus.

They were held overnight and brought before the council the

next morning, and Luke lists who was in the room.

Annas was there, Caiaphas was there, the same family, the

same chamber, the same men who had handled the trial.

And they opened with a question. By what power or

what name did you do this? Acts chapter 4 verse 7.

Acts 4:7

Caiaphas had heard those fishermen before. Peter had stood in

his own courtyard on the night of the arrest, warming

himself at a fire, denying he knew anyone by that name.

Now the same man stood in front of the council

and said it straight. It is by the name of

Jesus Christ of Nazareth, whom you crucified, but whom God

raised from the dead, that this man stands before you healed.

Picture what that morning was for Caiaphas. He had done

everything correctly by his own reasoning. He had removed the problem,

kept the peace, protected the temple, and given Rome no

reason to move against him. And within a short time

he was sitting in the same seat, listening to the

same name, spoken more boldly than before by men who

had been too frightened to admit they knew Jesus a

few years earlier. The council conferred and found they had

nothing to charge them with because the healed man was

standing right there in front of them. All they could

do was tell them to stop talking. Caiaphas was removed

from office around the year 36 by Vitellius, the Roman

governor of Syria, who came down to Jerusalem and replaced him.

Eighteen careful years of managing Rome, and Rome ended it

in a single administrative decision— After that, he disappears from

the record entirely. No trial, no famous death, nothing. The

man who gave up one life to protect an institution

watched the institution keep going without him. There is a

footnote to his story that came almost two thousand years later.

In November of 1990, a construction crew, working on a

road in a park south of the old city of Jerusalem,

broke through the roof of a burial cave. Inside were

bone boxes, and one of them was decorated with unusual care,

carved with rosettes. On the side, scratched into the limestone,

was a name. Joseph's son of Caiaphas. Inside were the

bones of a man who had died at about sixty

years old. That is what remains of the most powerful

religious figure of his generation, a box in a cave

that a bulldozer found by accident. Herod Antipas lost everything

in stages, and each stage came from something he had

done himself. His marriage to Herodias had required setting aside

his first wife, who was the daughter of Aretas IV,

king of the Nabataeans to the south and east. She

did not wait around for the divorce. She left for

her father's territory, and the insult sat between the two

rulers for years until it turned into war. Around the

year 36, the armies met, and the forces of Antipas

were destroyed. The Jewish historian Josephus, writing later in that century,

records that many Jews at the time regarded the defeat

as God's judgment on Antipas for what he had done

to John the Baptist. That is how the people under

his rule read it. The prophet he silenced in a

cell was still speaking through the ruin of his army.

Then came the last mistake. The Emperor Tiberius died, and Gaius,

the man history remembers as Caligula, took the throne. Caligula

gave a royal title to Agrippa, who was the nephew

of Antipas and the brother of Herodias. A member of

the family now had the crown that Antipas had wanted

for forty years, and his wife would not let it rest.

She pushed him to go to Rome in person and

ask the Emperor for the same rank. Around the year 39,

he sailed. Agrippa sent letters ahead of him, accusing him

of stockpiling weapons and conspiring against Rome. The emperor listened

to the accusations, stripped Antipas of his territory and his money,

handed it all to Agrippa, and sent him into exile

in Gaul, in what is now France. Herodias was offered

the chance to stay behind. She chose to go with him.

Neither of them saw Galilee again. He went to Rome

to ask for a crown and came away without a country.

The man who had wanted to see a sign so badly,

who had been given an entire profit and answered him

with an executioner, spent his last years in a province

at the edge of the empire with the title still

out of reach. And he is remembered today for exactly

one thing. He is the man Jesus would not talk to.

Pilate lasted a few more months than the other two,

and then the same pattern closed over him. In the

year 36, a Samaritan man gathered a crowd at the

foot of Mount Gerizim, the mountain the Samaritans held sacred,

promising to uncover holy objects he claimed Moses had buried there.

People came armed, and the gathering was large. Pilate responded

the way he had responded to every crowd in his career.

He sent troops, blocked the road, and there was a slaughter.

The Samaritan leadership took a formal complaint to Vitellius, the

same Roman governor of Syria who removed Caiaphas. Vitellius ordered

Pilate to sail to Rome and explain himself to the

emperor in person. Pilate went, and before he arrived, Tiberius died.

From that moment, the historical record simply closes over him.

He does not appear again in any reliable source. Whatever

happened to the governor of Judea after he stepped off

that ship, nobody knows. Later, Christian writers passed around stories

about a miserable end, but they were written centuries afterward,

and none of them can be checked. The most powerful

Roman in the region walks off the page in the

middle of a sentence. What survives of him is small

and strange. In 1961, Italian archaeologists digging in the ruined

theatre at Caesarea found a block of limestone that had

been reused as a building stone in a stairway. Turned over,

it carried an inscription with his name and his title,

Prefect of Judea. It is the only inscription ever found

that names him. There is also a thin copper alloy ring,

dug up years ago at a hilltop fortress that Herod

the Great had built south of Jerusalem, and only properly

cleaned and read in recent years, with the name Pilate

stamped around the outside in Greek. A reused stone and

a cheap ring. And then there is the other thing

that survives, which is far larger— Every Sunday, in churches

on every continent, Christians stand and say aloud that Jesus

Christ suffered under Pontius Pilate. His name was written into

the creed for a practical reason. It fixes the death

of Jesus to a real governor, in a real province,

in a dateable stretch of history, so that no one

could ever file it away as a story that happened

once upon a time. Pilate spent that morning trying to

keep his name off the decision. His name is now

attached to it permanently, spoken by more people in a

single weekend than ever lived in the province he governed.

Now look at the three of them together, because the

mourning was not the same for each man, and the

difference is worth noticing. Caiaphas asked Jesus who he was,

and received the clearest answer Jesus ever gave about his

own identity. Pilate asked him about kingship and truth and

received a real conversation, the longest exchange Jesus had with

any official in the Gospels. Herod Antipas asked many questions

and received silence. Three men, three approaches, three different responses

from the same prisoner on the same morning. The pattern

underneath is not hard to see. Caiaphas wanted an answer,

even if he wanted it for the wrong reason, and

he got one. Pilate wanted a way out, and he

was given the truth twice, and told plainly where the

real authority in the room came from. Antipas wanted entertainment.

He had been given John the Baptist for months and

had traded him for the approval of dinner guests, and

when he finally stood in front of the one John

had pointed to, there was nothing left to say to him.

Something else links them, and it is more uncomfortable than

the power. All three were afraid. Caiaphas was afraid that

one movement out of Galilee would bring the legions down

on the temple and end everything his family had built.

Antipas was afraid of how he would look to his

guests if he took back an order given in front

of them, and a prophet died over that. Pilate was

afraid of a letter reaching Rome with his name on it.

None of them woke up that day intending to be

remembered as the men who killed the Son of God.

They were protecting a position, a reputation, a career— That

is how most terrible things get done. Not by monsters

with a plan, but by frightened people making the safe choice,

one step at a time, until there is a cross

on a hill, and no one in the story is

willing to say they chose it. There is one more

thing the three of them shared. Every one of them

made the calculation that Rome was the safest thing to

hold on to. Caiaphas kept his office by never giving

Rome a reason to act. Antipas named a city after

the emperor and sailed to the capital to beg for

a title. Pilate sent a man he had called innocent

to a cross because a crowd used the word Caesar

against him. Rome removed all three of them anyway, within

four years. The thing each of them protected himself with

was the thing that finally took everything away. There is

a small scene at the cross that ties all of

this together, and it involves Pilate one last time. He

had a notice prepared and fastened above the head of

the crucified man, written in three languages, so that anyone

passing could read it. Jesus of Nazareth, the king of

the Jews. The chief priests came to him immediately and objected.

They wanted it changed to say that the man had

claimed to be king. Pilate refused. What I have written,

I have written. John 19.20 22. The one sentence Pilate

would not take back was a true one. He had

bent on everything else that morning, on the verdict, on

the evidence, on his own repeated finding of innocence. And

then he planted his feet on a sign. He almost

certainly meant it as a last insult to the men

who had cornered him. What he actually did was publish

the truth over the head of the Son of God

in the three main languages of the known world, and

then refused to edit it. That is the pattern running

through this entire story. Three courts handled Jesus, and every

one of them produced a false result. The religious court

called him a blasphemer. The royal court treated him as

a curiosity. The Roman court declared him innocent and killed

him anyway. All three verdicts were overturned within three days

by the only court that has never been wrong. And

notice who carried the news of that reversal. Not one

of the three men in power, but the frightened followers

who had scattered the The same Peter, who had denied

knowing him in the courtyard of Caiaphas, was the one

standing before the council a few years later, saying the

name out loud. Every man with authority that morning ended

his story, losing what he had. The men with nothing

ended up carrying the message across the empire. Here is

why this matters for the person listening to this today,

in a house that may be too empty, in a

body that may be tired, carrying something that has never

been made right. You have watched people get away with things.

Most of us have. Someone lied about you and it worked.

Someone took what was yours and there was no consequence

you ever got to see. Someone hurt a child or

a marriage or a reputation and life carried on and

nobody seemed to notice but you. And somewhere in the

middle of that, you started to wonder whether God is

slow or distant or simply not watching this part. Caiaphas, Antipas,

and Pilate were the three most powerful men in that

region on the day they killed Jesus of Nazareth. Between

them they held the temple, the throne of Galilee, and

the authority of the Roman Empire. Not one of them

kept any of it. And here is the part worth

holding on to. None of them was struck down in

the street. There was no lightning, no earthquake aimed at

a house. God did not answer them with a display.

He simply let time do what time does to everything

that is built on protecting yourself while finishing without any

announcement at all the thing he had actually come to do.

That is usually how it works. It is slower than

we want, it is less dramatic than we imagine, and

it is completely certain. But there is something else in

this story that should not be missed, and it is

the more important half. Peter did not stand in front

of that council to gloat. He stood there and told

them how to be saved. The men who had sent

Jesus to the cross were the first people in Jerusalem

to be offered forgiveness for it, out loud, to their faces,

by the followers of the man they had killed. The

door was not closed to Caiaphas. It was opened wider

to him than to almost anyone, and he was the

one who walked away from it. If you are carrying

something you are ashamed of, understand what that means. The

men who handled Jesus on the worst morning in history

were still invited in. Nothing you have done has put

you further outside than they were. Nothing. So if you

are tired tonight, or old, or forgotten by people who

used to call, or waiting on a justice that has

not arrived yet, hold on to what actually survived from

that morning. The high priest is a name scratched on

a bone box. The tetrarch is a footnote who died

in exile. The governor is a stone in a museum

and a line in a creed. And the man, all

three of them condemned, is alive, and he knows your name,

and he has never once looked at a person who

came to him and said there was nothing left to

be done. If this video helped you grow deeper in

God's Word, I want to personally invite you to be

part of what we are building here. Every video on

this channel takes many hours of study and careful research

to make sure we bring you content that is faithful

to Scripture and worthy of your time. If you would

like to support this mission and help us keep making

these videos, you can find a link in the description

below to give a one-time gift or become a monthly supporter.

Every gift, no matter the size, goes directly toward creating

more content like this. And if you are not in

a position to give right now, that is completely fine.

The best thing you can do is subscribe, share this

video with someone who needs to hear it, and keep

studying God's Word with us. Thank you for being here,

and may God bless you richly.