Sermon
Women We Should Know and Honor: Clotilda, Bertha, and Balthild: Three Women of the Early Medieval Church
Publisher transcript
Transcript
-
Wonderful, thank you. Well, it is our privilege today to have Kevin Hoffman with us to leaven
-
this series by throwing in some seeds from the early Middle Ages. And even though I have
-
heard of these women, you could torture me on the rack and I probably couldn't supply
-
a whole lot. So I am very much looking forward to this. Kevin is a fifth year, you'd think
-
sixth year given all the knowledge he has, but fifth year PhD student here in history.
-
And he with his wife has been part of the fellows program too at Rivendell. So glad to have him
-
here. You will very much enjoy this as I will. We're going to tag team today. So Kevin's going
-
to begin and cover three women, and then I will bring up the caboose with another profile
-
or two, depending upon our time. But please, Kevin, take your time and come on and inform
-
us about some women we should know. Good morning. So last week we were in the world of the Roman
-
Empire in late antiquity, a world which for all its drawbacks was a more civilized world than the
-
world which we will be exploring this morning. The world I'm speaking of is the early Middle Ages.
-
Not only that, we are looking at the earliest of the early Middle Ages. Often called the Dark Ages,
-
I hope to shine a couple of spotlights on some women whose names are almost certainly unfamiliar
-
to most of you, perhaps with the exception of John. If there are times where John has to make
-
heroic leaps and bounds from one source to another to string together a story we can follow, imagine
-
how some parts of the early Middle Ages make one want to throw their hands up in despair at our lost
-
and confusing sources. This world is also strange and foreign to us. It has been said that the past is a
-
foreign country. They do things differently there. Because of our unfamiliarity and the poor survival
-
of our sources, I will perhaps spend a bit more time on context than in previous weeks. But you might say,
-
why, if the Dark Ages are so dark, ought we to study them? Well, this period seems to me to be a good one
-
to investigate for three reasons. First, history is cool and it's my area of research, so you're kind of
-
stuck with me talking about it. Better get used to it. Second, this period is not well known and is
-
helpful to explore all the periods of the church. Because the church of the past is the heritage of
-
the church present. Third, we are in the church formerly known as St. Bonifaces, about whom I would
-
be happy to talk at some point, but that's for a different discussion. He has a wonderful letter that
-
he wrote about being a missionary in pagan lands of Europe, essentially saying, it's cold, rainy, dark.
-
Please send books. He, like these women I am going to talk about, were early medieval Christians.
-
But to make sense of the world of barbarians, we will need to briefly explore the end of the mighty
-
Roman Empire. Just before 300, the Roman Empire was split down the middle into two main administrative
-
regions. Each with two emperors. Right here is the split. Although these divisions were often ignored,
-
on the whole, the system lasted until the end of the western half of the empire. Due to a series of
-
civil wars, great power competition to the east, barbarian incursions, plague, climate change, and
-
collapsing central authority, the western half of the Roman Empire broke apart, while the eastern half
-
managed to stick around until the 15th century. And finally, by 476, there was no emperor in the west.
-
There were, however, lots of barbarians in what was Roman territory. Now, I think we have an image in
-
our mind of barbarians. They probably look a bit like this. They have become quite popular in, well,
-
pop culture. This is from a recent video game, actually. Big hairy men dressed in dirty furs,
-
smelling of stale sweat and beer, worshipping pagan gods. Well, some of that might be true. But this
-
doesn't capture one thing. The barbarians wanted to be Roman. In fact, the office of the commander of all
-
the Roman armies was often held by a Romanized barbarian. Look at this image. So this guy actually is a
-
Romanized barbarian. He's the head of all the Roman armies in the end of the fourth century, and he is the
-
picture of late antique Roman general. Part of that's because the Romans had begun adopting barbarian
-
styles. He's wearing pants. And partially, the barbarians have adopted a lot of Roman-ness.
-
But back to barbarians. A major difference between the Romans and these barbarians was their faith.
-
When the fourth century began, Christianity was not a legal religion. In a little over a decade,
-
it was a tolerated religion. And by the late fourth century, Christianity was the only legal religion
-
within the empire. The barbarians, however, were not Christians. When they arrived in contact with
-
the Romans, they were, without exception, pagan. Once they reached the borders of the empire, they often
-
converted to Arianism rather than Orthodox Christianity. Now, when I say the name Arian, I don't want you
-
thinking 1930s and 40s Germany in racial politics. This Arianism doesn't imply anything about race.
-
It is named after a man called Arius. For those not up on their fourth century church controversies,
-
Arians believed that the son was created, not begotten. In other words, Christ isn't God in the
-
same way the father is. This was a major controversy of the fourth century. And now we recognize this as
-
problematic, as did the church of the period. But if that weren't enough, the issue went deeper than
-
heresy. Deeper than heresy? How is that possible? Well, Arianism had become not only the religion of
-
these barbarians, but also a cultural marker. Once religion passes into culture, it becomes almost
-
impossible to disentangle. To these barbarians, their Arianism was bound up with their German-ness,
-
and vice versa. They couldn't abandon their German-ness, so too they couldn't abandon their
-
Arianism. And this is where our story begins. You see where it was divided? That's actually the last
-
bit of the Western Roman Empire. He dies in exile. We begin our story in what is modern France.
-
While Southern Europe was ruled mostly by Arian tribes, so these were Arians, these were Arians,
-
these were Arians, these were Arians, some of these were Arians, these were Arians. Everybody except
-
these guys and these guys, who were pagans, were Arians. Orthodox Christianity was not a barbarian
-
religion at this time. The Franks arrive in the north of France over the Rhine River. That's right over
-
here.
-
We don't really know much about their early history, but their kings claim to be descended from a sea
-
monster. I take this to mean he was a pirate, but make of it what you will.
-
When the Franks enter onto the scene, they had not yet abandoned their old gods, and when they came
-
into the Roman Empire, they arrived in a world of mainly Christians. Perhaps it is understandable,
-
but the Romans living in France didn't feel overly inclined to evangelize to the angry-looking,
-
long-haired kings of the Franks. Remember, hairy barbarians. The Franks began to expand all
-
throughout France, destroying little kingdom after little kingdom. This doesn't even capture the
-
number of little, little kingdoms and petty kings that existed at this time.
-
And eventually, the Franks had expanded to most of France.
-
But rather than destroy the little kingdom of the Burgundians, the king, Clovis, married a Burgundian
-
princess named Clotilda. This marriage dramatically altered the course of European history, for you see,
-
Clotilda was an Orthodox Christian. And by Orthodox, I mean mainly here that she was not an Arian.
-
As with most individuals in the pre-modern world, we aren't quite sure when Clotilda was born.
-
Given that she was born at her father's new capital, where he took up residence in 473,
-
we can guess that she was born sometime after that. So let's say around 474.
-
Likewise, it isn't really clear how or when she became a Christian. Perhaps it was part of her
-
father's submission to the dying Roman Empire in 475, two years before the last Roman Emperor was
-
kicked out. We don't entirely know. What we do know is that in the late 480s and early 490s,
-
the Burgundian kingdom descended into a civil war between four brothers, and Clotilda's father was
-
killed by one of his brothers in 493. She fled to a different brother of her father's. A little
-
confusing, I recognize. Clovis, the king of the Franks, took advantage of the civil war.
-
In marrying Clotilda in 493, he joined in on this civil war. Clovis thus became a major power player
-
in the former territories of the Western Roman Empire. But unknown to him, or at least not
-
understood by him, there was an ongoing war for his soul. Clotilda vigorously sought the conversion
-
of her husband. Soon after their marriage, their first son was born, and Clovis, perhaps surprisingly,
-
allowed his son to be baptized into the Catholic faith. Sadly, the son fell ill and passed away soon
-
afterwards. Clovis, perhaps understandably, blamed Clotilda's god. But he allowed her to have their
-
second son baptized. Clearly, the conviction of Clotilda was such that it was persuasive to a barbarian
-
king. And a little grace from God could help her, please. But an intense moment of our story, this
-
son, the second, also fell ill. But he recovered. The future kings of the Franks would be raised in
-
their mother's faith, rather than that of their father. But Clotilda was unable to reach her husband
-
yet. The warrior king continued pushing southwards, doing his warrior thing. In either 496 or 507,
-
depending on which battle it was, Clovis found himself in a difficult military situation,
-
and the battle was going poorly. Our historian from the period says that he called on God,
-
the God of his wife, when the battle was going poorly. And after winning the battle,
-
he was baptized. Perhaps he was looking for support from the Catholic clergy that still were around in
-
France. Or perhaps he was hoping that the Eastern Romans
-
might come and help them against the other barbarian tribes.
-
Maybe it was actually a true change of heart. We don't know. But this meant that the Frankish
-
leadership moved from paganism straight to Orthodox Christianity, unlike all the others that went to
-
Arianism first. We do know that Clovis had Arian family members. And he certainly had pagan family
-
members. But he didn't turn to them. The faith of Clotilda was his closest tether to Catholicism.
-
This not only meant that the Franks had Christian leadership, but it made it acceptable to be a
-
Christian at all levels of society. One king becoming a Christian among many wouldn't have been
-
significant on its own. But as it happens, the Franks became the most powerful kingdom in Europe,
-
thereby assuring Christian Orthodoxy would supplant Arianism across all of Europe.
-
The church hierarchy soon would not be looking east to the Roman Empire, but to France to protect
-
them from the Arian barbarians. All of this goes back to Clotilda. Moving forward from this point,
-
it would be Catholic Orthodoxy which spread to the new barbarians. This brings us to our second woman.
-
Bertha was a Frankish princess, and we know even less about her than we did about, well, Clotilda.
-
She was the great-granddaughter of Clovis and Clotilda, who was engaged to be married to a barbarian
-
king from England. Now, in the end of the 6th century, there were somewhere between
-
seven and ten kingdoms in England, Anglo-Saxon kingdoms in England. That's ignoring all the
-
British, that is, Celtic-speaking kingdoms. It may come as a bit of a surprise, but it is really hard
-
to find good maps of places we aren't quite sure of the borders of for a time we aren't entirely certain
-
of from about 1,500 years ago. The man that Bertha was engaged to was Ethelbert. Great name. Let's bring it back.
-
The King of Kent down here, right next to France, about as close as you can get.
-
Now, we don't have any lifetime depictions of him or her. However, this one's pretty close. This is a
-
depiction of him from, I think, the 8th or 9th century, so a couple hundred years off, but that's as close as we can get sometimes.
-
However, we do have some depictions or things of lifetime contemporaries. So, I study coins mainly, and this is a wonderful coin.
-
This is not Ethelbert, but his son, Eadbald, another wonderful name. The Anglo-Saxons could name them.
-
So, see the legend above his head? Yes, those are, in fact, letters.
-
Aud, Wald, Re.
-
Eadbald. Kind of close.
-
On the next slide,
-
we see the next-door neighbor to Kent,
-
the Kingdom of East Anglia.
-
If you saw the recent movie, The Dig, about the excavation of the Sutton Hoo ship,
-
this is what the site looked like.
-
And this is the reconstruction of the helmet found there,
-
in the boat burial.
-
Just looking at the helmet and the type of burial,
-
it's clear that if we are in a Christian world,
-
it is a Christian world which is very attached to its pagan past.
-
But in all likelihood,
-
England was almost entirely pagan.
-
I think we should be reminding ourselves here
-
of the hairy barbarian image.
-
This is perhaps a little surprising,
-
that England was pagan,
-
not that barbarians are hairy.
-
England was part of the Roman Empire,
-
but when the Roman military left the island in 409,
-
there were definitely still Christians there.
-
I'll tell you a story you might know.
-
There was a British boy,
-
who was born a little before the Romans left.
-
He was picked up by slavers and sold in Ireland.
-
Slavery will be a recurrent theme in this talk,
-
so keep that in mind.
-
This boy would escape and find freedom
-
before going back to Ireland
-
and becoming their patron saint.
-
Yes, I am talking of St. Patrick.
-
The world of Celtic Christianity was alive at this time,
-
but the Anglo-Saxons seem not to have noticed.
-
Just like with the Romans in France,
-
the British were none too keen to evangelize
-
to their axe-wielding, fur-wearing,
-
Thor-worshipping barbarian neighbors.
-
In the coming century,
-
once Christianity became firmly ensconced in Ireland,
-
they began sending missionaries to England.
-
A country which had never been part of the Roman Empire
-
became Christian before the rest of those regions
-
that had been a part of the Roman Empire.
-
But I digress.
-
Enter Bertha.
-
You remember the legacy of faith that Clotilda left to her sons?
-
Bertha was a Christian,
-
and she insisted that if she were to marry this pagan king,
-
that she be allowed to worship her god.
-
Sorry.
-
That she be allowed to worship her god.
-
She brought her chaplain with her,
-
a bishop, Lüthard.
-
There we go.
-
Isn't he handsome?
-
We can see his name right here.
-
Well, if you can't make Lüthard,
-
however that's spelled,
-
out of this word soup,
-
I can't really blame you.
-
Yeah.
-
That's an L.
-
Looks like an X.
-
E.
-
Only has two arms.
-
U-D-A-R-U-S.
-
Lüthard.
-
Oh, there's a D here.
-
Düs.
-
E-P-S.
-
Bishop.
-
So, yeah.
-
This isn't a very literate world.
-
In fact, it's a very, very illiterate world.
-
But anyways.
-
Bertha made sure that she had a chapel
-
in which to worship,
-
right in Canterbury,
-
the capital of Kent.
-
Although, again,
-
the stubborn husband
-
refused to acknowledge
-
his wife was correct.
-
And it would take another
-
historical happenstance
-
for him to be converted.
-
Over 1,000 miles away in Rome,
-
Pope Gregory the Great
-
noticed two boys
-
being sold as slaves.
-
It is reported that
-
when he asked where they were from,
-
he was told they were Angli.
-
Angles, English.
-
His response was,
-
Non sunt Angli, said Angli.
-
They aren't Angles.
-
They're angels.
-
Presumably, Gregory
-
wasn't very familiar
-
with those with blonde hair.
-
Or perhaps they had
-
particularly nice voices.
-
In any case,
-
it spurred the Pope
-
to send a mission
-
to these angels in the north.
-
Remember,
-
hairy barbarians.
-
Gregory sent for a couple of monks
-
to be apostles to the English.
-
Augustine of Canterbury,
-
not his more famous namesake,
-
who was from North Africa.
-
This Augustine
-
led the mission to England.
-
When they arrived,
-
you can guess
-
which kingdom
-
they set up in.
-
Yep,
-
they arrived in Kent
-
and set up their new church
-
right next to Bertha's Chapel,
-
which is the oldest
-
continuous place
-
of Christian worship
-
in England.
-
Now, I don't doubt
-
that God could have orchestrated
-
a favorable reception
-
even among the pagans.
-
But surely,
-
Queen Bertha's faith
-
made her husband
-
more naturally inclined
-
to accept these foreign leave,
-
that he would have viewed
-
these foreigners
-
as representatives
-
of a foreign power.
-
Now, it is usually
-
Gregory the Great
-
and Augustine
-
who get credit
-
for the conversion
-
of the English,
-
and on one level,
-
they do deserve
-
considerable credit.
-
But the English
-
had a bad habit
-
of civil wars
-
and one kingdom
-
taking over another
-
and missionaries
-
getting kicked out
-
repeatedly,
-
sometimes the same one.
-
The church
-
had a beachhead
-
in England
-
with Bertha,
-
and it wasn't going
-
to be pushed back
-
across the channel.
-
Then again,
-
that doesn't mean
-
that England
-
didn't start sending
-
their own missionaries,
-
like Boniface,
-
for whom this church
-
used to be named.
-
But some of those missionaries
-
weren't sent to France
-
with the intention
-
of preaching.
-
With the intention
-
of preaching,
-
some of them
-
arrived in,
-
like St. Patrick,
-
as slaves.
-
A woman named
-
Baltild arrived
-
in France
-
as a slave.
-
Now,
-
I said I would
-
come back to this,
-
and here seems
-
like a good place
-
to do so.
-
Slavery was common
-
in the ancient
-
and medieval worlds.
-
While it was certainly
-
the case that the economy
-
of the early Middle Ages
-
was not slave-based,
-
like the ancient world,
-
at some times
-
and in some regions,
-
there were a considerable
-
number of slaves.
-
Some have argued
-
that the slavery
-
was the basis
-
of the early medieval economy,
-
with the barbarian kings
-
selling what they had
-
lots of,
-
people,
-
in exchange for what
-
they had none of,
-
gold,
-
to North Africa,
-
the Eastern Roman Empire,
-
and the Middle East.
-
Slavery in the ancient world
-
didn't have the same
-
racial connotation
-
it has today.
-
Typically,
-
most were prisoners of war
-
from the next-door
-
little kingdom.
-
Another category of slave
-
were those who were
-
temporarily,
-
usually,
-
sold themselves
-
into slavery
-
to receive protection
-
or to pay off a debt
-
or a bit of both.
-
So what was
-
Baltild's status?
-
There seems to be
-
some debate.
-
The earliest sources
-
we have
-
don't mention
-
her status at all.
-
But about a century
-
after her death,
-
it was said that
-
she was aristocratic
-
or royal.
-
We can't be certain,
-
but I think there are
-
good indications
-
that she was actually
-
low-born.
-
Born around 626,
-
she was sold
-
into the house
-
of the most powerful man
-
in one of the
-
Frankish kingdoms
-
after the king.
-
At some point,
-
he,
-
the second most powerful man,
-
wanted to marry her.
-
But apparently,
-
he had competition.
-
So did the king.
-
One might immediately
-
suspect,
-
aha,
-
proof that she was royal.
-
Why else would a king
-
want to marry her
-
except to solidify
-
an alliance?
-
And there are
-
other things
-
that might
-
indicate that
-
she was royal.
-
there you go.
-
This is a
-
seal matrix.
-
So the part
-
that's inserted
-
into wax
-
to create
-
the image.
-
These are actually
-
concave.
-
So this would have
-
been pressed into that.
-
But this was actually
-
found in England,
-
not in France.
-
And again,
-
this is more literate
-
than some,
-
although the A
-
is in fact upside down,
-
as is the L,
-
B,
-
A,
-
L,
-
D,
-
Balde,
-
Hildes.
-
Baldehild.
-
But the Frankish kings
-
are a bit odd.
-
No fewer than
-
three kings
-
and perhaps
-
four married slaves
-
who then rose
-
to be queen.
-
And sometimes,
-
after the king's death,
-
ruled in their own name.
-
A source
-
about a hundred years
-
after these events
-
describes the king
-
as descending to insanity
-
before his death
-
at the age of only 18.
-
It is possible
-
that he was considered
-
unstable
-
and was thus married
-
off to a slave.
-
This happened
-
in the Frankish world
-
that feeble-minded kings
-
were often married
-
to slaves.
-
Perhaps they were seen
-
to be able
-
to control the king
-
sufficiently
-
for the second
-
most powerful person
-
to be able
-
to actually do
-
the real running
-
of the country.
-
But this,
-
the fact that he dies
-
or that he descends
-
into insanity
-
before he's dying
-
might imply
-
that she was just
-
a run-of-the-mill slave
-
with no aristocratic background.
-
With the death
-
of her husband
-
and her sons
-
in minority,
-
she took sole rulership
-
of the kingdom
-
as regent
-
on behalf of her son.
-
She had a powerful coalition
-
backing her,
-
including the man
-
who purchased her
-
and a bishop
-
named Eligius.
-
So,
-
I thought this was
-
kind of cool.
-
E-L-I-G-I-L-E-G
-
of Eligius.
-
And here's a modern one.
-
He is a saint,
-
he is a bishop,
-
and he was also
-
the king's monnier
-
for a period.
-
That's pretty rare
-
that we actually know
-
who the monniers are.
-
They usually aren't bishops.
-
He's lowborn.
-
He's not an aristocrat.
-
This coalition
-
that she established
-
actually was fairly successful.
-
She had a very successful regency.
-
And her son
-
eventually ascended
-
to the throne,
-
a success
-
in times
-
where assassination
-
was the norm.
-
during her time
-
as regent,
-
she sent missionaries
-
to Germany,
-
fought simony,
-
the buying or selling
-
of church offices
-
in the church,
-
and founded numerous monasteries
-
for the preservation
-
of knowledge.
-
One scholar
-
has contended
-
that she was
-
the last competent monarch
-
of the dynasty
-
that began with Clovis
-
in the 470s.
-
This is 130 years later,
-
the last competent monarch
-
of this dynasty.
-
Her husband
-
is sometimes thought of
-
as the first of the,
-
they're called
-
the Roi Fainel,
-
meaning the do-nothing kings,
-
which seems
-
particularly harsh.
-
But if that is all
-
she had done,
-
been a successful regent,
-
she would have been
-
really interesting.
-
In the 19th century,
-
jumping many centuries here,
-
in the Luxembourg gardens
-
in Paris,
-
a series of 20 sculptures
-
of the Queens of France
-
were commissioned.
-
Among these,
-
20,
-
Baltild is represented.
-
Why her?
-
Well,
-
she might be considered
-
an abolitionist.
-
It is perhaps
-
no coincidence
-
that the promulgation
-
of a new decree
-
ending slavery
-
in the French colonies
-
where it remained.
-
It had already been removed
-
in some of the colonies
-
and then added back
-
during the Napoleonic period.
-
A promulgation
-
of a new decree
-
ending slavery
-
in the French colonies
-
where it remained
-
was from the same year
-
as the statue.
-
France had actually been
-
at the leading end
-
of abolition
-
in the modern era,
-
but also
-
in the pre-modern.
-
Baltild made huge reforms
-
in France,
-
including making
-
the purchasing
-
of slaves illegal.
-
Much in the way
-
that the Atlantic slave trade
-
was made illegal
-
before the extirpation
-
of slavery
-
within the boundaries
-
of the U.S.,
-
Baltild could not go
-
so far as to free slaves
-
within France.
-
Her position
-
was far too precarious
-
for something
-
so wide-sweeping.
-
She promulgated
-
a law
-
that made slaves
-
free upon arrival
-
in France.
-
This would be reiterated
-
in 1315
-
by a subsequent
-
French king.
-
Could her experience
-
of being a slave
-
have led to this result?
-
I think so.
-
But let's tie up
-
the story
-
I've been telling today
-
in a nice,
-
neat bow.
-
Returning to the map
-
we began with,
-
maps are great,
-
we follow the story
-
of a Burgundian princess.
-
Here we are.
-
A Burgundian princess
-
named Clotilde
-
who married
-
the Frankish king.
-
Brought him
-
not only to Christ,
-
but kept the kingdom
-
of France away
-
from denying
-
the divinity of Christ.
-
That legacy of faith
-
left by Clotilde
-
was picked up
-
by her great-granddaughter,
-
Bertha,
-
who married
-
an English king.
-
From over here.
-
Insisting that she
-
be allowed
-
to practice her faith
-
in the pagan land
-
of England.
-
When missionaries
-
were sent from Rome
-
to England,
-
they found a home
-
in this little kingdom
-
of Kent.
-
And from there,
-
Christianity would spread
-
throughout England.
-
Decades later,
-
an English slave
-
would be sold
-
into France.
-
She would become queen
-
and would begin
-
the long fight
-
to extirpate slavery
-
from Christendom.
-
Perhaps we don't have
-
all the details
-
of the lives
-
of these women,
-
but their impact
-
is clear.
-
Thank you.
-
Thank you.
-
Any questions?
-
Comments?
-
Kevin, is there
-
any evidence
-
that the abolition
-
of the slave trade,
-
I guess purchasing slaves,
-
do we notice
-
any sort of effect?
-
did it,
-
or is it just,
-
is it just in,
-
in legislation
-
or we're aware
-
of that
-
or is there
-
a way to trace
-
or pick up
-
any effects
-
of this?
-
So,
-
on the extirpation
-
of slavery,
-
did it have
-
an impact?
-
Actually,
-
the Merovingian period,
-
so that's the period
-
in Frankish history
-
we're looking at,
-
is at a low point
-
for finds
-
of slave shackles.
-
So,
-
archaeologically speaking,
-
in the late antique period,
-
slave shackles
-
are found
-
all across Europe
-
in the ruins
-
of Roman-style villas
-
all over.
-
In the Merovingian period,
-
it's at an all-time low
-
that it drops precipitously.
-
Now,
-
I don't remember
-
exactly when the dating
-
of it dropping is,
-
but it is in this period.
-
And subsequently,
-
after the Merovingian period,
-
when the second
-
most powerful people,
-
the mayors of the palace,
-
as they were called,
-
they rise up
-
and create their own dynasty,
-
kicking out the do-nothing kings,
-
they actually re-institute slavery
-
and you start finding
-
slave shackles again
-
on the periphery
-
of the kingdom,
-
but not within
-
the heartlands of France.
-
So,
-
we do see impacts.
-
Now,
-
to what extent
-
is it just,
-
they just had
-
the Scandinavians
-
sell the slaves,
-
let them pass through,
-
they weren't keeping
-
the slaves,
-
but picking up
-
some tolls?
-
Well,
-
we don't entirely know,
-
but
-
there seems to be
-
an impact,
-
at least archaeologically speaking.
-
Yeah.
-
John,
-
would you like to...
-
Yes, yes.
-
All right,
-
thank you.
-
One thing
-
was absolutely
-
certain.
-
She would not
-
be staying in India.
-
And she was not
-
going to become
-
a missionary.
-
Never.
-
India was altogether
-
too hot,
-
too dusty,
-
too overcrowded,
-
with most
-
of its seething
-
masses dirty
-
or destitute,
-
leprous
-
or lice-ridden.
-
Besides,
-
a missionary bungalow
-
was no place
-
for a blossoming
-
young lady
-
fresh out of college.
-
There she is.
-
With dreams
-
of balls
-
and bows,
-
dresses
-
and dances,
-
and eventual
-
marriage to a millionaire.
-
neither
-
would the expectation
-
generated by
-
the Scudder family
-
tradition
-
sway her.
-
What if
-
her grandfather,
-
John,
-
was America's
-
first foreign
-
medical missionary?
-
What if
-
all his sons
-
had followed
-
in his footsteps?
-
What if
-
all the other
-
grandchildren
-
were planning
-
on doing the same?
-
not
-
Ida Scudder.
-
She
-
would not
-
be forced
-
into the family
-
mold.
-
She had only
-
returned to India
-
to nurse
-
her ailing mother
-
back to health.
-
Then
-
it would be back
-
to the good life
-
in America.
-
That much
-
was certain.
-
Or so
-
she was quite
-
sure
-
until
-
all suddenly
-
changed
-
that one
-
terrible
-
night.
-
She was up
-
late
-
in her bungalow
-
when her
-
reading was
-
interrupted
-
by a knock.
-
It was a
-
high-class
-
Brahmin.
-
Amal,
-
I desperately
-
need your help.
-
My wife,
-
a young girl
-
of 14,
-
is dying
-
in childbirth.
-
Oh,
-
exclaimed
-
Ida
-
in swift
-
sympathy.
-
It's my
-
father you
-
want.
-
He's the
-
doctor.
-
He's right
-
next door.
-
I'll take
-
you to him.
-
What?
-
exclaimed
-
the Brahmin
-
in haughty
-
outrage.
-
Permit
-
a man
-
to look
-
upon my
-
wife.
-
It is
-
better
-
that she
-
should die.
-
Ida
-
was aghast.
-
There's
-
nothing you
-
can do,
-
explained
-
her father.
-
It's the
-
custom.
-
It would
-
violate
-
his caste
-
law.
-
Shaking,
-
she returned
-
to her
-
book.
-
Then,
-
again,
-
footsteps
-
sounded on
-
the veranda,
-
this time
-
a Mohammedan.
-
Salaam,
-
madam,
-
may Allah
-
give you
-
peace.
-
if you
-
could help
-
me.
-
It is
-
my wife.
-
The child
-
will not
-
come.
-
I am
-
afraid she
-
is dying.
-
Ida
-
gasped.
-
My father
-
will help.
-
He's...
-
Madam,
-
the voice
-
was apologetic
-
but firm.
-
You don't
-
understand our
-
ways.
-
Only men
-
of the
-
immediate
-
family
-
enter a
-
Muslim
-
woman's
-
room.
-
It is
-
you,
-
a woman
-
whose
-
help I
-
seek,
-
not a
-
man's.
-
But I
-
can't
-
help,
-
sputtered
-
Ida.
-
I'm not
-
even a
-
nurse.
-
Then my
-
wife must
-
die,
-
returned the
-
Muslim in
-
stalled
-
resignation.
-
It is
-
the will
-
of Allah.
-
Ida
-
was left
-
with her
-
book but
-
could not
-
read.
-
She lay
-
awake on
-
her bed.
-
It was
-
then the
-
third
-
knock
-
came.
-
To her
-
horror,
-
another
-
with the
-
same
-
plea.
-
He too
-
had a
-
young wife
-
dying in
-
labor.
-
Would I
-
to come?
-
Don't you
-
understand?
-
There is
-
nothing I
-
can do.
-
I could
-
not sleep
-
that night.
-
It was
-
too terrible,
-
Ida
-
later recalled.
-
Here
-
were three
-
young girls
-
dying
-
because
-
there was
-
no woman
-
to help
-
them.
-
I spent
-
the night
-
in anguish
-
and prayer.
-
I think
-
that it
-
was the
-
first time
-
I ever
-
met God
-
face to
-
face.
-
with the
-
first light
-
came the
-
beating of
-
the tom
-
toms,
-
the death
-
message.
-
For all
-
three girls
-
had died
-
that night.
-
Ida
-
remained in
-
a room
-
wrestling
-
with God.
-
When she
-
finally emerged,
-
she found
-
her father
-
and mother
-
and resolutely
-
announced,
-
I'm going
-
to America
-
to study
-
to be a
-
doctor
-
so I
-
can come
-
back here
-
and help
-
the women
-
of India.
-
And that's
-
just what
-
she did.
-
Cornell
-
Medical
-
College
-
had just
-
opened its
-
doors to
-
women.
-
and Ida
-
was among
-
the first
-
of its
-
graduating
-
class,
-
the class
-
of 1899.
-
The Cornell
-
Quarterly
-
tells us
-
that when
-
the women
-
entered the
-
class or
-
the operating
-
theater,
-
the men
-
students would
-
stamp their
-
feet and
-
blow kisses.
-
I suppose
-
some things
-
never change.
-
And that
-
was not
-
the only
-
thing that
-
the men
-
did to
-
harry
-
the poor
-
women.
-
Ida
-
received
-
a
-
marriage
-
proposal
-
just
-
before
-
she had
-
to take
-
her final
-
round of
-
exams.
-
She passed
-
the exams
-
and she
-
passed on
-
the proposal.
-
As for
-
her residency,
-
she determined
-
to fulfill it
-
under her
-
father.
-
Who better
-
to prepare
-
her for
-
the peculiar
-
challenges
-
India would
-
afford?
-
One week
-
away from
-
sailing,
-
it was
-
suggested
-
she ought
-
to raise
-
$8,000
-
to build
-
a women's
-
hospital
-
in India.
-
Not a
-
lot of
-
time,
-
but she
-
threw herself
-
into the
-
task,
-
calling on
-
anyone she
-
could think
-
of.
-
But
-
dollars
-
came in
-
at a
-
trickle,
-
an ounce
-
of water
-
to quench
-
an elephant's
-
thirst,
-
as she put
-
it.
-
Hopes
-
were pinned
-
on one
-
final interview
-
where Ida
-
poured out
-
her heart
-
and told
-
of that
-
terrible
-
night
-
of the
-
three
-
knocks.
-
Yet no
-
commitment
-
came,
-
and it
-
seemed there
-
would be no
-
women's
-
hospital.
-
But,
-
by chance,
-
there sat
-
in an
-
adjacent
-
room a
-
man who
-
overheard
-
Ida's
-
plea.
-
Much
-
moved,
-
the man
-
came forward.
-
Name
-
the hospital
-
in memory
-
of my
-
beloved
-
wife,
-
Mary
-
Tabor
-
Schell,
-
said the
-
stranger,
-
and handed
-
her a
-
check for
-
$10,000.
-
Ida
-
had her
-
hospital,
-
but there
-
was one
-
more thing
-
she would
-
not leave
-
for India
-
without.
-
A woman
-
evangelist
-
who could
-
labor with
-
her to
-
bring
-
gospel to
-
the women
-
within the
-
dark,
-
secluding
-
walls.
-
November
-
22nd,
-
1899,
-
Ida set
-
sail.
-
With her
-
was her
-
girlhood
-
friend,
-
Annie
-
Hancock,
-
to labor
-
at her
-
side as
-
an evangelist.
-
It was
-
a challenging
-
start.
-
Her
-
father,
-
from whom
-
she expected
-
to receive
-
her residency,
-
died just
-
months after
-
her return.
-
Her first
-
patient,
-
so far
-
gone by
-
the time
-
she was
-
summoned,
-
died,
-
as did
-
the next.
-
Scarcely a
-
good commendation
-
for her medical
-
skills for the
-
locals.
-
But finally,
-
after a
-
successful
-
conjunctivitis
-
case,
-
her miraculous
-
healing powers
-
were proclaimed.
-
and the
-
veranda of
-
her 8-by-10-foot
-
room,
-
which served
-
as her
-
dispensary,
-
was thronged
-
from dawn
-
to dusk.
-
One day,
-
a mother
-
came in,
-
too terrified
-
to hold
-
her diseased
-
baby.
-
Ida called
-
upon Salome,
-
the cook.
-
Salome
-
appeared,
-
sporting
-
spotless
-
hands and
-
a smile
-
of unmistakable
-
eagerness.
-
See,
-
Missy?
-
Scrubbed
-
with soap.
-
Don't have
-
to tell
-
Salome.
-
She held
-
the baby
-
firmly,
-
but gently.
-
Then,
-
while Ida
-
attended to
-
the mother,
-
Salome
-
turned to
-
the next
-
patient.
-
Parvati
-
wishes more
-
medicine for
-
her baby's
-
sore eyes.
-
Shall I
-
give her
-
some of
-
this?
-
Pointing to
-
the bottle
-
of boric
-
acid solution.
-
Why,
-
yes,
-
Salome,
-
but how
-
did you
-
know?
-
I know.
-
I have
-
been watching
-
Missy.
-
Ida's
-
eyes lit
-
up.
-
Yes,
-
of course,
-
I will
-
start a
-
nursing school
-
and Salome
-
will be
-
the first
-
pupil.
-
And so
-
it was.
-
There's
-
an old
-
photo of
-
the first
-
nurses she
-
had in
-
her school.
-
Am I
-
right in
-
front of
-
this?
-
This is
-
being seen
-
at all.
-
Okay,
-
okay.
-
Don't want
-
you to
-
miss the
-
pictures.
-
But soon,
-
Dr.
-
Ida had
-
set her
-
sights
-
higher.
-
If she
-
could train
-
nurses,
-
why not
-
doctors?
-
The inspiration
-
met with
-
incredulity
-
all around.
-
Indian
-
women
-
become
-
doctors
-
and compete
-
against men
-
from India's
-
seven medical
-
schools?
-
girls?
-
But you
-
scarcely had
-
to be
-
sexist to
-
think the
-
situation
-
implausible.
-
With Dr.
-
Ida, the
-
sole
-
instructor
-
at a
-
school
-
that possessed
-
only two
-
books,
-
one
-
microscope
-
and one
-
skeleton?
-
There she
-
goes,
-
training them.
-
But Ida
-
was
-
indomitable.
-
She didn't
-
cut her
-
clinics,
-
there she
-
is,
-
some of
-
her
-
clinics,
-
or her
-
roadside
-
peripatetic
-
dispensary.
-
She'd have
-
this ox
-
cart,
-
well here
-
it is,
-
this ox
-
cart that
-
would go
-
around into
-
the countryside
-
where she
-
would bring
-
her medical
-
expertise and
-
aid to
-
the locals.
-
So kind
-
of a
-
traveling
-
dispensary.
-
that she
-
is there.
-
She's
-
the one
-
in her
-
clear medical
-
garb of
-
the time.
-
No,
-
she continued
-
all those
-
things,
-
but added
-
teaching the
-
entire medical
-
school curriculum
-
to her
-
14 lambs,
-
as she
-
called them.
-
Widespread
-
prediction was
-
that not
-
one of her
-
girls,
-
would pass
-
their board
-
exams.
-
As the
-
results were
-
announced,
-
stress
-
mounted,
-
for 80%
-
of the
-
men across
-
India had
-
failed.
-
The women's
-
scores were
-
revealed last.
-
Every one
-
of them
-
had passed,
-
and several
-
of them
-
in the top
-
rank,
-
placing Ida's
-
Women's
-
Medical College
-
at the
-
head of
-
all the
-
medical
-
schools
-
of India.
-
There are
-
some of the
-
first women
-
graduates.
-
Teaching the
-
girls is
-
no headache
-
in comparison
-
to feeding
-
them,
-
joked
-
Ida.
-
For with
-
Christian,
-
Hindu,
-
and
-
Mohammedan
-
students,
-
many with
-
caste or
-
religious
-
culinary
-
obligations,
-
there was
-
no simple
-
ladling out
-
of the
-
same pot
-
of stew.
-
Finally,
-
she divided
-
them into
-
three menu
-
groups,
-
vegetarians,
-
meatarians,
-
and
-
agarians,
-
she called
-
them.
-
A great
-
day of
-
rejoicing
-
was the
-
long-awaited
-
opening of
-
the Mary
-
Tabor
-
Shell
-
Memorial
-
Hospital.
-
There it
-
is.
-
Although,
-
the new
-
white iron
-
beds,
-
as you can
-
see,
-
were objects
-
of terror
-
as well
-
as wonder
-
to the first
-
patients.
-
Accustomed
-
to sleeping
-
on mats
-
at floor
-
level,
-
the frightened
-
occupants
-
felt as if
-
they were
-
being placed
-
on dangerously
-
high shelves.
-
Ida would
-
regularly
-
discover
-
patients
-
wrapped
-
carefully
-
in their
-
sheets
-
lying
-
under
-
the bed
-
instead
-
of on
-
them.
-
Well,
-
if only
-
all the
-
trials
-
were that
-
trivial.
-
Keeping
-
the hospital
-
funded
-
and supplied
-
proved a
-
Herculean
-
task,
-
especially
-
in the
-
years coinciding
-
with the
-
two world
-
wars and
-
the depression.
-
Thankfully,
-
Ida found a
-
Scotch
-
administrator,
-
literally from
-
Scotland,
-
but also Scotch,
-
who could
-
stretch a
-
rupee to
-
Rangoon,
-
and the
-
hospital never
-
had to
-
close its
-
doors.
-
Neither
-
were these
-
years always
-
free from
-
political
-
turbulence.
-
Once,
-
during a
-
tense time
-
of martial
-
law,
-
Ida,
-
in order
-
to visit
-
a critically
-
ill
-
Mohammedan
-
patient,
-
donned a
-
disguise and
-
countervened
-
the curfew.
-
Another
-
experience she
-
would never
-
forget involved
-
delivering a
-
wealthy young
-
Muslim woman
-
of a
-
beautifully
-
formed,
-
but
-
precariously
-
delicate
-
baby girl.
-
Day and
-
night,
-
Ida
-
wrestled
-
to keep
-
the infant
-
alive,
-
and did
-
not rest
-
till she
-
was sure
-
the tiny
-
life was
-
out of
-
danger.
-
But the
-
family regarded
-
the might
-
with glum
-
disfavor,
-
not only
-
for her
-
gender,
-
but her
-
birth,
-
they said,
-
had occurred
-
on an
-
inauspicious
-
day.
-
Ida was
-
confident,
-
however,
-
that given
-
little time,
-
the child
-
would win
-
their hearts.
-
Sometime
-
later,
-
while about
-
other things,
-
Ida suddenly
-
felt a
-
strong impulse
-
to check
-
on the
-
baby.
-
She flew
-
through the
-
hospital to
-
S-ward.
-
All was
-
quiet behind
-
the screen
-
concealing
-
the bed.
-
Too
-
quiet.
-
Pulling
-
aside
-
the
-
curtain,
-
she saw
-
a pillow
-
being pressed
-
hard against
-
the surface
-
of the bed.
-
Snatching it
-
away,
-
there was
-
the baby,
-
already blue
-
in the face,
-
only moments
-
short of
-
being smothered.
-
How could
-
you?
-
Born on
-
unlucky
-
day,
-
will of
-
Allah she
-
die?
-
You don't
-
want her
-
to die,
-
you take
-
her.
-
All right,
-
said Ida,
-
I will.
-
And she
-
named the
-
girl
-
Mary Tabor
-
after the
-
hospital,
-
the first
-
of what
-
would become
-
a great
-
number of
-
unwanted
-
daughters,
-
Ida took
-
under wing.
-
Never
-
married,
-
she had
-
children
-
galore.
-
It was
-
not just
-
love her
-
patients received,
-
it was
-
Christian
-
love.
-
And
-
according to
-
her earnest
-
prayer,
-
none would
-
linger long
-
without learning
-
something of
-
it.
-
Once a
-
Muslim woman
-
recovering from
-
a sudden
-
attack of
-
acute
-
malarial
-
mania
-
seized
-
Ida's
-
hand.
-
Tell me
-
why you
-
did not
-
lose your
-
temper with
-
me when
-
I was
-
quite out
-
of my
-
mind.
-
Before
-
Ida could
-
answer,
-
a Hindu
-
woman in
-
the next
-
bed responded,
-
don't you
-
know why?
-
That's what
-
their god
-
is like.
-
Long
-
suffering
-
and slow
-
to
-
anger.
-
Well,
-
on her
-
88th
-
birthday,
-
Cornell
-
University
-
Medical
-
College
-
conferred
-
upon its
-
first woman
-
graduate
-
its highest
-
honor,
-
the award
-
of distinction.
-
The usual
-
requirement of
-
receiving the
-
award in
-
person was
-
kindly waived,
-
for Dr.
-
Ida was
-
loathe to
-
leave her
-
beloved
-
hospital,
-
a hospital
-
so much
-
more now
-
than even
-
she could
-
ever have
-
imagined that
-
night of
-
the three
-
knocks.
-
beds.
-
The one
-
bed for
-
healing
-
in her
-
father's
-
mission
-
bungalow
-
had now
-
become
-
more than
-
1,000
-
beds.
-
The first
-
class of
-
14 lambs
-
had swelled
-
to
-
900
-
each year.
-
the staff
-
of two,
-
herself and
-
a cook
-
turned nurse
-
Salome,
-
had multiplied
-
to include
-
380
-
doctors,
-
400
-
nurses,
-
and 270
-
paramedical
-
workers,
-
serving
-
nearly
-
2,500
-
patients
-
in a
-
single
-
day.
-
Okay.
-
I wonder
-
what we
-
might
-
undertake
-
that is
-
worthy of
-
our life
-
investment.
-
Have we
-
heard any
-
knocks
-
in the
-
night
-
which might
-
serve as
-
a clue?
-
How far
-
we have
-
come,
-
said the
-
aged
-
Ida
-
at the
-
last.
-
Oh,
-
God has
-
been so
-
very good
-
to us.
-
Indeed.
-
Well,
-
let me
-
stop there
-
and open
-
it up
-
for any
-
questions.
-
Look at
-
that smile.
-
Isn't
-
that a
-
wonderful
-
expression
-
of a
-
good
-
life
-
well
-
lived?
-
What
-
paramedia
-
was she?
-
It was
-
in
-
Velour.
-
So,
-
yeah,
-
I should
-
have had
-
maps.
-
I should
-
have had
-
maps.
-
It is.
-
It is.
-
In fact,
-
I had a
-
couple of
-
these from
-
old
-
transparencies,
-
but I
-
jumped on
-
Google,
-
and you
-
can actually
-
Google,
-
like they've
-
got this
-
thing called
-
Google
-
image,
-
and you
-
can go
-
there.
-
And
-
they had
-
pictures,
-
some old
-
ones,
-
of her,
-
and they
-
have pictures
-
of the
-
hospital.
-
Now,
-
I had a
-
missionary
-
friend.
-
Well,
-
you remember
-
Dan
-
Nicholas.
-
He had
-
gone over
-
and he
-
had visited
-
the hospital
-
and he
-
sent me
-
some
-
wonderful
-
pictures
-
of it,
-
and it's
-
still going
-
strong.
-
still there,
-
a wonderful
-
heritage.
-
There's
-
Dorothy
-
Clark has
-
written a
-
wonderful
-
biography of
-
her.
-
It's a fun
-
one if you
-
want to
-
read it.
-
And there's
-
also one
-
that kind
-
of chronicles
-
the history
-
of the
-
entire
-
Scudder
-
family.
-
It's
-
called
-
A Thousand
-
Years in
-
Thy Sight,
-
because they
-
totaled
-
up all
-
of the
-
years of
-
medical
-
labor that
-
was done
-
in India
-
by all
-
of the
-
family,
-
and it
-
totaled up
-
to about
-
a thousand
-
years.
-
It's a
-
wonderful
-
title.
-
A thousand
-
years in
-
thy sight.
-
And in
-
that hospital
-
and from
-
some of
-
that family,
-
some of
-
the cutting
-
edge research
-
globally,
-
worldwide,
-
has been
-
done,
-
apparently,
-
on things
-
like leprosy
-
and other
-
things,
-
really,
-
really
-
remarkable
-
accomplishments
-
from there.
-
So,
-
yes.
-
All right.
-
Well,
-
team,
-
it looks like
-
we're at
-
time,
-
so I
-
will not
-
do,
-
but maybe
-
sometime in
-
the future,
-
we'll just
-
have to
-
pick up
-
this series
-
again,
-
because we
-
have by
-
no means
-
exhausted
-
the
-
extraordinary
-
women
-
whose
-
names and
-
lives we
-
should know
-
and honor.
-
So,
-
hopefully,
-
there can
-
be a
-
part B
-
sometime,
-
because I
-
even have
-
more prepared,
-
ready to go
-
at some point.
-
It would be
-
lots of fun
-
to do,
-
but thank you
-
for your
-
time,
-
and hopefully,
-
this will be
-
an inspiration
-
to us all.
-
I think of
-
how Paul
-
said,
-
imitate me
-
as I
-
imitate Christ,
-
and what
-
makes these
-
women such
-
extraordinary
-
leaders is
-
what makes
-
any leader
-
an extraordinary
-
leader,
-
which is
-
simply this,
-
that they
-
are good
-
followers of
-
Christ.
-
They are
-
exemplary
-
followers of
-
Christ.
-
So,
-
if you
-
follow Christ
-
well,
-
you are
-
a leader.
-
You are
-
exemplary
-
in that,
-
and you
-
can be a
-
great
-
blessing
-
to those
-
of us
-
that can
-
look and
-
be inspired
-
by your
-
lives as
-
we seek
-
to follow
-
Christ
-
faithfully
-
to both
-
women and
-
men.
-
Well,
-
thank you.
-
We will
-
see you
-
next time
-
as we
-
have
-
occasion
-
to do
-
so.
-
Ming
-
for
-
to
-
her
-
father
-
decision