Sermon
Global Misssions
Publisher transcript
Transcript
-
Well, last week we looked at Jesus as the model for our mission endeavor, examining the pattern of his incarnate life and drawing out implications for our missionary practice.
-
! And this morning, in our companion study, if you will, we turn to the Apostle Paul with the same ambition.
-
How is the Apostle a model for us in our missionary lives?
-
Now, in some circles, when one moves from Jesus to Paul, it is often contrasts which are asserted, suggesting that Paul somehow strikes off on his own path, even departing from the patterns laid out by our Lord.
-
It is therefore worthwhile to commence our consideration of Paul by asking how, if at all, the Apostle took up the pattern established by Jesus, or did he depart from it in any way?
-
Do we find contrast, as is commonly alleged, or do we, in fact, see correspondence and continuum?
-
Now, in our study of Jesus last week, we drew our portrait from the Father's sending of the Son incarnationally, drawing out features from that astounding fact.
-
We observed that this involved a great going out, first of all.
-
The Son did not remain in heaven, but went out into the far country of humanity, seeking out the lost.
-
The gospel narratives, again and again, of Jesus are filled with a phrase,
-
and he went out, and he went out, and he went out.
-
Well, I ask you, could there be a more faithful and fervent follower of this model than the Apostle Paul going out to the far-flung Gentiles?
-
As he told the Romans, I make it my ambition to preach the gospel, not where Christ has already been named,
-
but to those who have never been told of him, Romans 15, 20.
-
And among his animating ambitions was to herald the gospel in Spain, which geographically would have been the end of the earth from him.
-
So no divergence from Jesus here.
-
We also observed of the Son's incarnation that he came in person.
-
His mission brought him face-to-face with those that he sought, involving a deep personal engagement.
-
And what of Paul's missionary practice?
-
Well, the phrase face-to-face is repeated again and again in his correspondence,
-
and not just as a formulaic expression, but as a principled commitment.
-
Given his familiarity with the inside of jails, he was at times kept from this desire,
-
torn away from you, brothers and sisters, for a short time,
-
in person but not in heart, as he described it to the Thessalonians.
-
But such separation was to him an anguish.
-
And he, quote,
-
endeavored the more eagerly and with great desire, as he told them,
-
to see you face-to-face.
-
First Thessalonians 2.
-
If he did have freedom,
-
he preferred prolonged stays to passing ones.
-
For, as he told the young Corinthian believers,
-
I do not want to see you just in passing.
-
I hope to spend time with you, if the Lord permits.
-
First Corinthians 16.
-
And as with the Master,
-
his personal engagement was thick, deep, rich, and devoted.
-
Being so affectionately desirous of you, he tells the Thessalonians,
-
we were ready to share with you not only the gospel of God,
-
but also our very own lives,
-
because you had become so very dear to us.
-
First Thessalonians 2.8.
-
He likens his relationship, in that same verse,
-
to them as that of a nursing mother taking care of her own children.
-
Surely this reflects faithful correspondence to the pattern of the Master.
-
Paul loses no marks here.
-
We also noticed in the incarnation of the Son,
-
a deep identification with those to whom he came,
-
making himself like them in everything but their sin.
-
So how was the Apostle on following this particular melody?
-
To the Corinthians, he explained that
-
he sought to identify with and adapt to those that he sought to reach
-
in every possible way.
-
I have become all things to all people.
-
Now, since we will shortly comment further on this commitment,
-
as pretty much the compact articulation of his modus operandi,
-
we'll say no more at present,
-
but that Paul here embodies the pattern of Christ in excelsis.
-
We further noticed that the mission of Christ was marked by a pattern of
-
consistent and conspicuous self-emptying.
-
Was the Apostle a stranger to this?
-
Well, to the young believers in Philippi,
-
he describes his missional life as one great continued pouring out,
-
and compared it to a drink offering being poured out on the sacrificial offering of the Philippians' faith.
-
In other words, his life was a poured out libation to enhance the Philippians' offering of their lives to God.
-
Philippians 2.17.
-
And finally, we observed that the son's incarnational mission was marked by a stupendous costliness.
-
His life was that grain of wheat that fell to the ground and died to bring forth much fruit.
-
Well, do we catch an echo here in the missionary labors of the Apostle?
-
Well, as Paul explained to the Corinthians,
-
without the slightest trace of self-pity,
-
rather recognizing it as precisely the pattern of Christ and the purpose of God,
-
he writes,
-
So death works in me, but life in you.
-
2 Corinthians 4.12.
-
The spiritual life that came to the Corinthians came at a cost.
-
It cost the life of the Apostle,
-
the slow dying of the missionary.
-
In this, his missionary life is the perfect correspondence to the pattern of Christ.
-
So, when Paul described the Thessalonians as having become, quote,
-
imitators of us and of the Lord,
-
1 Thess 1.6,
-
he was not offering two divergent paths or models.
-
For the Apostle's missionary life was simply a reiteration of our Lord's missionary pattern.
-
He merely contextualized in its different settings the life of his Lord.
-
As he told the Corinthians,
-
imitate me as I imitate Christ, 1 Corinthians 11.1.
-
So, I think the conclusion, unavertible,
-
Paul's missionary model does not diverge from Christ's.
-
Christ was the very inspiration and exemplar for Paul.
-
Important to start with that because so often in the literature,
-
you see an emphasis of the contrast between the Apostle and Jesus.
-
But, far from this correspondence,
-
making Paul's model of missions merely reiterative,
-
the Apostle brings a singular theological acumen
-
in both his articulation and application
-
of Christ's incarnational-shaped mission.
-
And that's where we want to go.
-
Well, I'll just, as an illustration,
-
let's just take the last considered feature,
-
the stupendous costliness
-
of the incarnate mission of the Son.
-
Okay, how does Paul develop this?
-
How, in Paul's mind,
-
are Christ's disciples
-
to follow in Christ's footsteps
-
in regard to our Savior's suffering?
-
So, just an example of how he does theological development here.
-
There is theologically developed continuity,
-
but also contrast.
-
Paul tells the Corinthians,
-
we share abundantly in Christ's sufferings.
-
2 Corinthians 1.5.
-
Now, this phrase,
-
the sufferings of Christ,
-
or Messiah,
-
Christ simply Greek for Messiah,
-
is part of a broader understanding,
-
sometimes referred to as the Messianic woes.
-
Okay, this notion of the Messianic woes
-
was distilled from Old Testament prophets,
-
Isaiah, Jeremiah, Daniel, Hosea, Micah.
-
I can't develop that now,
-
but it was developed by Jewish teaching
-
and held that the triumphal Messianic age
-
would be preceded by woes.
-
In the Hebrew word,
-
it was basically birth pangs,
-
akin to the birth pangs
-
that a woman would suffer in labor.
-
Okay, and here's the interesting thing.
-
These Messianic woes,
-
this suffering would be endured
-
not by the Messiah himself,
-
but rather would be born
-
by those associated with him.
-
It's fascinating.
-
Now, the New Testament writers,
-
including Paul,
-
took this up,
-
a suffering intense,
-
but of fixed duration
-
and even fixed quantity,
-
which would be the lot
-
of Messiah's people,
-
that is,
-
Christ's disciples.
-
Christ's death and resurrection
-
had inaugurated the Messianic age
-
and his people,
-
living now in these last days,
-
were called to endure tribulation
-
in fulfillment of the scriptures
-
and in fulfillment of Jesus' own words
-
until the full measure
-
of this appointed suffering
-
was complete
-
and Christ returned.
-
Now, it's in this conceptual backdrop
-
that we have illuminated
-
Paul's otherwise cryptic statement
-
to the Colossians.
-
Do you remember that in Colossians 124
-
where Paul writes,
-
I do my share
-
of filling up
-
what is lacking
-
in Christ's afflictions?
-
There's Colossians 124
-
if you want to look there.
-
Now,
-
he is speaking
-
of these sufferings
-
of the Messiah
-
or these Messianic woes.
-
Now, notice significantly,
-
he says,
-
filling up.
-
Now, a filling up
-
implies that there is
-
a fixed amount.
-
He's referring
-
to the fixed measure
-
of the intense sufferings
-
that must be endured
-
by Christ's disciples
-
before Christ returns.
-
So, what is the sum
-
of suffering
-
that is to be endured?
-
Well,
-
it is the sum
-
of what it will cost
-
to deliver,
-
declare,
-
and display
-
the gospel
-
through the ends
-
of the earth,
-
both near and far.
-
As Jesus told his disciples,
-
the gospel of the kingdom
-
shall be preached
-
in the whole world
-
for a witness
-
to all the nations
-
and then
-
the end shall come.
-
Matthew 24, 14.
-
As Paul explains
-
again to the Colossians,
-
I fill up
-
what is lacking
-
in Christ's sufferings,
-
verse 24,
-
by,
-
he continues,
-
by filling up
-
or fully carrying out,
-
same word in the Greek,
-
by fully carrying out
-
the preaching
-
of the gospel,
-
verse 25.
-
Do you see that link?
-
See that link?
-
The way we fill up
-
the afflictions
-
of the Messiah,
-
the messianic woes,
-
is by fully carrying out
-
the preaching
-
of the gospel.
-
This is a wonderful
-
theological articulation.
-
You see,
-
according to Paul,
-
according to his insight
-
and understanding,
-
as disciples,
-
we enter into
-
a partnership
-
in suffering
-
with the Master.
-
That is indeed
-
what fellowship means.
-
It's partnership
-
in a cause.
-
The cause
-
is redemption.
-
And the disciple
-
partners with the Master
-
in paying the cost
-
of redemption.
-
redemption.
-
Now,
-
we need to be
-
really,
-
really careful here
-
and nuanced
-
because I don't want you
-
to misunderstand.
-
Both Christ
-
and his disciples
-
suffer
-
to reconcile
-
the world
-
to God,
-
to bring many
-
sons and daughters
-
to glory.
-
We suffer
-
in the same cause
-
as the Savior,
-
but our suffering
-
is not
-
of the same
-
character.
-
This is really,
-
really important
-
or we can kind of
-
go off the rails here.
-
The suffering
-
our Lord
-
endured
-
to bring many
-
to glory
-
none
-
but he
-
could bear.
-
He must
-
tread the wine
-
press alone
-
as Isaiah says
-
in Isaiah 63.3.
-
He alone
-
took the cup
-
of the Father's wrath.
-
So,
-
his sufferings
-
were
-
propitiatory.
-
The disciples
-
are
-
propagatory.
-
His,
-
the cost
-
of atoning.
-
Ours
-
is but
-
the cost
-
of announcing.
-
His,
-
the procuring
-
of a great salvation.
-
Ours,
-
merely
-
the proclaiming
-
and parading
-
that great salvation
-
to the ends
-
of the earth.
-
And yet,
-
our
-
part two
-
bears
-
a very
-
real
-
cost.
-
And it is
-
so fundamental
-
for our
-
discipleship,
-
for the disciple
-
to take up
-
that call
-
that Paul
-
can unpack
-
it,
-
what it means
-
as simply
-
knowing Christ
-
is to have
-
fellowship
-
in his sufferings.
-
That I might
-
know him,
-
Christ,
-
he writes
-
to the
-
Philippians,
-
Philippians 3.10,
-
that is
-
the fellowship
-
of his
-
sufferings.
-
So,
-
this then
-
is the call
-
of the disciple,
-
fundamentally.
-
The call
-
to partnership
-
in Christ's
-
sufferings.
-
The call
-
to take up
-
a share
-
of the
-
messianic
-
woes,
-
the painful
-
birth pangs
-
that are
-
bringing his
-
return
-
through
-
helping
-
fully
-
to carry
-
out
-
our gospel
-
mission.
-
It is
-
the mortification
-
of mission.
-
Whatever
-
pain and
-
suffering
-
comes to
-
us
-
in
-
faithfully
-
prosecuting
-
the gospel
-
mission.
-
Is that
-
not
-
marvelously
-
illuminating?
-
Is that
-
not
-
wonderfully
-
clarifying?
-
Thank you,
-
Paul.
-
These are
-
so helpful.
-
So,
-
even though
-
there's
-
perfect
-
continuity
-
and continuum
-
with Paul's
-
pattern
-
and Jesus'
-
pattern,
-
he articulates
-
it and
-
he applies
-
it so,
-
so helpfully.
-
So,
-
there's an
-
example.
-
But,
-
I want
-
to focus
-
on another
-
element
-
of model
-
missions
-
the apostle
-
offers us.
-
Paul is
-
the master
-
of what
-
we might
-
call
-
the
-
creative
-
contextualization
-
of the gospel.
-
That's what
-
I want us
-
to focus
-
on.
-
So,
-
let's
-
first
-
observe
-
his
-
practice
-
of
-
contextualization,
-
then clarify
-
the principle
-
behind the
-
practice,
-
and then
-
finally,
-
note some
-
of the
-
perfect
-
but precarious
-
balance
-
it achieves
-
that plots
-
a course
-
between two
-
perilous pitfalls.
-
apostles.
-
So,
-
that's where
-
we're going.
-
Okay.
-
So,
-
first,
-
the apostle's
-
practice
-
of creative
-
contextualization.
-
The apostle,
-
his adept
-
contextualization
-
could be
-
illustrated from
-
any number
-
of gospel
-
encounters
-
that the
-
narrative of
-
Acts
-
supplies.
-
I mean,
-
I wish
-
we had
-
a whole
-
month
-
to do
-
this.
-
But,
-
perhaps
-
Acts
-
17
-
serves
-
superlatively
-
to show
-
how Paul
-
adapts his
-
gospel message
-
to his
-
audiences.
-
So,
-
Acts 17.
-
You probably
-
know it
-
pretty well.
-
You can
-
open it
-
if you'd
-
like.
-
Now,
-
Paul would
-
be the
-
first to
-
insist
-
that there
-
is only
-
one
-
gospel.
-
You
-
recall his
-
vehement
-
assertion to
-
the Galatians
-
when astounded
-
that they
-
had so
-
quickly
-
defected
-
to,
-
quote,
-
a different
-
gospel,
-
not that
-
there is
-
another
-
one.
-
Galatians
-
1,
-
6,
-
and 7.
-
Now,
-
notice,
-
contained
-
in that
-
statement
-
is the
-
insistence
-
that anything
-
different
-
from the
-
one and
-
only gospel
-
is no
-
gospel
-
at all.
-
Okay,
-
so there's
-
just one
-
gospel.
-
Let that
-
be our
-
bedrock
-
as we
-
build our
-
understanding
-
of contextualization.
-
There is
-
but one
-
gospel,
-
and yet,
-
the one
-
and only
-
gospel can
-
be articulated
-
in different
-
ways,
-
and indeed
-
may well
-
need to be
-
articulated in
-
different ways
-
if it is to
-
gain a hearing
-
across diverse
-
audiences.
-
So Acts
-
17,
-
the chapter,
-
opens with
-
the apostle
-
declaring the
-
gospel to
-
a Jewish
-
or Jewish
-
adjacent,
-
maybe some
-
God-fearers,
-
Gentile God-fearers,
-
Jewish-adjacent
-
audience.
-
in the
-
setting of
-
a synagogue.
-
So how
-
does his
-
gospel
-
presentation
-
unfold there
-
in that
-
context?
-
Well,
-
Luke recounts,
-
he reasoned
-
with them
-
from the
-
scriptures,
-
from the
-
Jewish
-
scriptures,
-
explaining
-
and proving
-
that it
-
was necessary
-
for the
-
Christ to
-
suffer,
-
the Messiah
-
to suffer,
-
and to
-
rise from
-
the dead,
-
and saying,
-
this Jesus,
-
whom I
-
proclaim to
-
you,
-
is the
-
Messiah,
-
is the
-
Christ.
-
verses
-
one and
-
two.
-
In the
-
synagogue
-
setting,
-
the identity
-
of the
-
Messiah was
-
a burning
-
question.
-
And if
-
you wanted
-
to make
-
your case
-
credible and
-
compelling in
-
a synagogue,
-
you would
-
have to base
-
it on the
-
acknowledged
-
authority,
-
the scriptures,
-
the Jewish
-
scriptures.
-
And Paul had
-
become quite
-
skilled in
-
this approach,
-
and it proved
-
persuasive to
-
many,
-
as Luke
-
tells us.
-
But,
-
when he
-
travels on
-
to Athens,
-
he finds
-
himself in
-
a very
-
different
-
setting.
-
Not a
-
Jewish
-
synagogue,
-
but a
-
pagan
-
temple.
-
And as
-
well-versed
-
as Paul
-
surely was
-
in his
-
synagogue
-
evangelism,
-
he couldn't
-
just show
-
up and
-
then press
-
play.
-
Men of
-
Athens,
-
let us
-
take up
-
the burning
-
question of
-
the identity
-
of the
-
Messiah.
-
As you
-
well know,
-
Psalm 110
-
states,
-
no.
-
No,
-
this would
-
have been
-
utter gibberish
-
to the
-
Athenians.
-
The Greek
-
word for
-
Messiah meant
-
simply smeared
-
one.
-
And what is
-
this writing
-
he is referring
-
to?
-
No,
-
his audience
-
is coming
-
from such
-
a different
-
framework that
-
when he
-
speaks of
-
Jesus and
-
the resurrection,
-
they think
-
he's speaking
-
about two
-
deities.
-
Because in
-
their world,
-
usually deities
-
would show
-
up in
-
twos.
-
The major
-
deity in
-
his consort.
-
Jesus and
-
Anastasia,
-
resurrection.
-
Just thought
-
it was the
-
name of
-
his
-
concert.
-
Chrysostom
-
makes this
-
observation in
-
his writings.
-
And the
-
clue is
-
given,
-
he seems
-
to be a
-
preacher of
-
foreign
-
deities,
-
plural,
-
in verse
-
18.
-
That's how
-
garbled,
-
they're a
-
completely
-
different
-
framework.
-
Now,
-
Paul,
-
if he hopes
-
to be
-
comprehended
-
or even
-
given a
-
hearing,
-
he has
-
to adapt
-
to his
-
audience
-
and
-
recontextualize
-
his gospel
-
presentation.
-
He has
-
to connect
-
with something
-
that they
-
care about,
-
something native
-
to their
-
interests,
-
something expressed
-
in their
-
vernacular.
-
And this
-
is precisely
-
what he
-
does.
-
The cultural
-
portal he
-
finds for
-
the gospel
-
is the
-
aspiration in
-
Athenian
-
culture of
-
having a
-
comprehensive
-
catalog of
-
all the
-
deities.
-
You didn't
-
want to run
-
any risk of
-
leaving anybody
-
out because
-
they might
-
zap you
-
with ill
-
fortune.
-
So they
-
have to have
-
a complete
-
catalog.
-
Now,
-
picking,
-
I mean,
-
it's remarkable
-
how deft
-
a contextualization
-
he performs.
-
I mean,
-
this aspiration
-
that he latches
-
onto,
-
this aspiration
-
engages
-
with what
-
was culturally
-
pervasive.
-
It reflected
-
no eccentric
-
pocket of
-
interest.
-
Rather,
-
as he says,
-
as Luke
-
tells us,
-
the city
-
was full
-
of idols.
-
So he's
-
connecting with
-
something really
-
pervasive.
-
Neither was
-
it for the
-
Athenians a
-
matter of
-
tepid
-
indifference.
-
As Paul
-
observed,
-
they were
-
very religious,
-
verse 22.
-
Further,
-
it was a
-
matter around
-
which they
-
had acknowledged
-
and unresolved
-
questions.
-
As the
-
inscription read,
-
to the
-
unknown God.
-
They had
-
real questions
-
about this.
-
That's a
-
good way
-
to connect.
-
And he
-
connected with
-
deep streams
-
for it
-
contained
-
their
-
objects
-
of worship.
-
Anytime we
-
can figure
-
out what
-
the culture
-
worships,
-
we are
-
deeply
-
connecting.
-
So this
-
weaves a
-
rich fabric
-
of cultural
-
recontextualization
-
to embed
-
the gospel
-
in matters.
-
So when we
-
try to do
-
this,
-
we want
-
to try
-
to embed
-
the gospel
-
in matters
-
that are
-
to our
-
hearers,
-
pervasive,
-
prominent,
-
passion-laden,
-
puzzling,
-
and prized.
-
Those are the
-
things that we
-
want to connect
-
with.
-
And if we
-
fail to
-
recontextualize
-
the gospel,
-
connecting it
-
to matters
-
that matter
-
to our
-
hearers,
-
we will
-
simply,
-
and fatally,
-
reinforce a
-
sense,
-
perhaps even
-
a suspicion
-
or a
-
prejudice
-
on their
-
part,
-
that our
-
message is
-
utterly
-
irrelevant to
-
them.
-
Well,
-
there's so
-
much more
-
contextualizing
-
skill and
-
wisdom to
-
be culled
-
from Paul's
-
practice in
-
Athens.
-
You know,
-
you just
-
go,
-
there's so
-
much.
-
For instance,
-
he makes
-
his case
-
citing their
-
poets and
-
their
-
philosophers,
-
all kinds
-
of,
-
but we
-
must turn
-
to consider
-
to the
-
principle
-
behind the
-
practice.
-
The principle
-
behind the
-
practice.
-
His
-
principle
-
involves
-
motive,
-
aim,
-
and means.
-
Motive,
-
aim,
-
and means.
-
All
-
unfolded
-
in 1 Corinthians
-
9.
-
1 Corinthians
-
9.
-
Paul's
-
general
-
governing
-
principle
-
at the
-
fountainhead
-
of his
-
practice
-
is stated
-
in verse
-
23.
-
I do
-
all for
-
the sake
-
of the
-
gospel.
-
There's
-
the
-
motive.
-
That
-
could
-
well
-
serve
-
as the
-
apostle's
-
motto
-
inscribed
-
on his
-
missionary
-
travel
-
trunk.
-
I do
-
all for
-
the sake
-
of the
-
gospel.
-
And
-
for the
-
sake
-
of the
-
gospel,
-
he has
-
made
-
himself,
-
he says,
-
the servant
-
of all.
-
Verse
-
19.
-
And
-
this
-
universal
-
servanthood
-
is in the
-
service of
-
his aim.
-
verse 19.
-
To win
-
more to
-
Christ.
-
To win
-
more to
-
Christ.
-
And having
-
identified his
-
aim to win as
-
many as
-
possible to
-
Christ,
-
how does he
-
hope to
-
serve them
-
in order to
-
win them?
-
What means
-
does he
-
deploy?
-
Verse 20.
-
The next
-
verse.
-
To the
-
Jews, I
-
became as
-
a Jew
-
to win
-
Jews.
-
To those
-
outside the
-
law,
-
Gentiles,
-
as one
-
outside the
-
law,
-
like a
-
Gentile,
-
that I
-
might win
-
more of
-
them.
-
To the
-
weak,
-
I became
-
weak,
-
that I
-
might win
-
the weak.
-
That is,
-
Paul serves
-
them by
-
becoming
-
like
-
those he
-
seeks to
-
win.
-
That's how
-
he serves
-
them.
-
He adapts
-
himself to
-
them by
-
showing
-
sensitivity
-
and
-
versatility.
-
Sensitivity
-
and versatility.
-
Sensitivity.
-
What might
-
seem
-
unnecessarily
-
alien and
-
off-putting
-
to those I
-
seek to
-
win?
-
When I'm
-
with the
-
Jews, I
-
don't order
-
the pork
-
chop.
-
I keep
-
kosher.
-
That's
-
sensitivity.
-
When I'm
-
with the
-
Gentiles and
-
they offer
-
me a pork
-
chop, I
-
receive it
-
with thanks.
-
If the
-
pork chop
-
has been
-
offered to
-
an idol and
-
I happen to
-
be with one
-
who is of
-
tender conscience,
-
I turn it
-
down so as
-
not to be a
-
stumbling block.
-
And
-
Corinthians
-
expounds on
-
this.
-
Paul wants
-
to be aware
-
of any
-
and all
-
obstacles that
-
could be a
-
barrier to
-
their hearing
-
and embracing
-
the message
-
of Christ.
-
He doesn't
-
want to weigh
-
the gospel
-
down,
-
with a
-
host of
-
cultural
-
trappings.
-
He doesn't
-
want it to
-
appear or
-
be felt to
-
be more
-
alien than
-
it must
-
be.
-
And not
-
only is he
-
sensitive,
-
aware, he's
-
also versatile,
-
adaptable.
-
And not
-
only in his
-
person as
-
messenger,
-
standing with
-
his hearers in
-
solidarity, in
-
alignment with
-
kosher or
-
non-kosher,
-
Hebrew or
-
Greek,
-
the same
-
way that
-
Hudson Taylor,
-
you know,
-
pigtails and
-
platform shoes
-
in China,
-
just going to
-
blend in in
-
everything that
-
I can.
-
Not only in
-
his person,
-
but even in
-
the message
-
itself, not
-
just the
-
messenger, but
-
the message
-
itself,
-
adapting it
-
to the need
-
of his
-
hearers so
-
that it will
-
connect and
-
not confuse,
-
as we saw
-
demonstrated in
-
Athens so
-
marvelously.
-
Paul sits
-
loose to the
-
cultural trappings
-
as they are
-
not fundamental,
-
merely functional
-
for him.
-
Not fundamental,
-
merely functional.
-
He can present
-
Jesus as the
-
expected Messiah
-
in the synagogue
-
or as the
-
unknown God
-
at the
-
Necropolis.
-
Also,
-
is there not
-
something strange
-
about the
-
phrase,
-
to the Jews,
-
I became
-
a Jew?
-
Wait a minute,
-
Paul.
-
What do you
-
mean became a
-
Jew?
-
You are a Jew
-
of the tribe
-
of Benjamin,
-
a Hebrew of
-
Hebrews.
-
Yes,
-
but that's
-
not fundamental
-
to me.
-
I can
-
emphasize or
-
de-emphasize
-
that,
-
like a
-
cosmopolitan
-
can his
-
boyhood
-
accent.
-
Sometimes it's
-
useful in my
-
setting,
-
sometimes it's
-
not.
-
What I am
-
most fundamentally
-
is new
-
creation.
-
2 Corinthians
-
5,
-
17.
-
That is
-
my identity.
-
The Jew
-
or Gentile
-
bit is
-
largely
-
my
-
adaptability
-
for the
-
sake of
-
the gospel.
-
But of
-
course,
-
just because
-
these cultural
-
accessories are
-
not fundamental
-
doesn't mean
-
that they're
-
to be
-
despised.
-
Paul does
-
not relegate
-
to worthless
-
cultural
-
matters.
-
He simply
-
relativizes
-
them to
-
their missional
-
usefulness.
-
He asks,
-
what value
-
do they
-
have as
-
to my
-
aim for
-
winning
-
more to
-
Christ?
-
So,
-
for example,
-
though he
-
refused to
-
circumcise
-
Titus,
-
in Galatians
-
2,
-
3,
-
in order
-
to clarify
-
the gospel,
-
he thought
-
it useful
-
to circumcise
-
Timothy
-
to open
-
doors for
-
the gospel,
-
Acts 16,
-
1.
-
He states
-
his principle
-
tersely in
-
verse 22
-
of 1 Corinthians
-
9,
-
I have
-
become
-
all things
-
to all
-
that by
-
all means
-
I might
-
save some.
-
All things,
-
Paul?
-
That sounds
-
a rather
-
boundless
-
adaptability.
-
Well,
-
we notice
-
that he
-
feels free
-
to set
-
aside the
-
Jewish
-
law,
-
but he
-
clarifies
-
that is,
-
it is
-
not the
-
case
-
that
-
nothing
-
governs
-
me.
-
I am
-
not
-
outside
-
the
-
law
-
of
-
God,
-
but I'm
-
under
-
the
-
law
-
of
-
Christ,
-
verse 21.
-
So,
-
what bounds
-
this?
-
What bounds
-
this
-
adaptability?
-
We,
-
as
-
sensitive
-
and
-
adaptive
-
missionaries,
-
are
-
under the
-
standards
-
of our
-
Savior.
-
Paul
-
does what
-
he does
-
and how
-
he does
-
it
-
according
-
to the
-
pattern
-
of
-
Christ
-
and
-
his
-
gospel.
-
He
-
will
-
not,
-
nor
-
can
-
we,
-
for the
-
sake
-
of
-
the
-
gospel,
-
abandon
-
the
-
gospel
-
pattern
-
of
-
constraints.
-
Can't
-
do
-
that.
-
Like
-
Christ's
-
own
-
incarnational
-
identification
-
with us,
-
it is
-
in all
-
things
-
except
-
our
-
sinfulness.
-
Can't
-
adapt
-
to
-
that.
-
And
-
so,
-
in
-
seeking
-
to win
-
the
-
lost,
-
Paul
-
can
-
say,
-
to the
-
Jew I
-
became
-
as a
-
Jew,
-
to those
-
without the
-
law,
-
as without
-
the law,
-
to the
-
weak,
-
weak,
-
but he
-
cannot
-
say,
-
to the
-
drunk I
-
became a
-
drunkard,
-
to the
-
philanderer I
-
became a
-
philanderer,
-
to the
-
idolater I
-
became an
-
idolater.
-
Do you see
-
the difference
-
here?
-
Critical that
-
we get
-
that.
-
In our
-
zeal to
-
identify fully
-
with those
-
we seek
-
to win
-
to the
-
gospel,
-
we may
-
not
-
betray
-
the
-
gospel
-
itself.
-
So,
-
when Paul
-
declares,
-
I have
-
become all
-
things to
-
all people
-
that by
-
any means
-
I might
-
save some,
-
it's clear
-
that he
-
means by
-
all permissible
-
means,
-
any gospel
-
and cross
-
conforming
-
means.
-
Is that
-
clear?
-
Pretty
-
important.
-
Okay,
-
good,
-
good,
-
good,
-
good.
-
Well,
-
to further
-
refine our
-
grasp and
-
application of
-
Paul's
-
contextualizing
-
principle,
-
let's
-
consider one
-
final passage
-
which shows
-
how its
-
course is
-
cross-pressured
-
and sails
-
between a
-
fateful
-
scylla and
-
a fatal
-
charybdis.
-
So,
-
let us
-
finally observe
-
three,
-
the vital
-
balance
-
in contextualization.
-
The vital
-
balance in
-
contextualization.
-
1 Corinthians
-
1.
-
You might
-
want to
-
turn there.
-
1 Corinthians
-
1.
-
It's
-
Paul's
-
master
-
class
-
in the
-
subtleties
-
and sand
-
traps
-
of gospel
-
contextualization.
-
We find
-
Paul
-
having done
-
the thoughtful
-
cultural
-
analysis
-
required
-
of a
-
skilled
-
missionary.
-
He has
-
observed
-
and reflected
-
upon the
-
culture of
-
those he
-
seeks to
-
reach,
-
and he's
-
identified
-
some of
-
their
-
principal
-
values
-
and governing
-
concerns.
-
and these
-
will direct
-
and inflect
-
how he
-
will preach
-
the gospel
-
to them.
-
Here
-
is the
-
differentiating
-
sensitivity
-
and adaptability
-
that we've
-
observed.
-
So,
-
verse 22,
-
notice,
-
he's got his
-
cultural analysis.
-
Jews
-
demand
-
signs
-
and Greeks
-
seek
-
wisdom.
-
Two
-
different
-
things,
-
different
-
culture.
-
Sophia,
-
wisdom,
-
and
-
semion,
-
sign.
-
Sophia
-
and
-
semion.
-
The
-
Greeks
-
seek
-
an
-
explanation
-
of the
-
world.
-
The
-
Jews,
-
God's
-
intervention
-
in it.
-
The
-
Greeks,
-
they
-
seek
-
the
-
world's
-
pervading
-
principle
-
of
-
rational
-
meaning.
-
The
-
Jews,
-
a
-
mighty
-
demonstration
-
of
-
God's
-
saving
-
power
-
in the
-
world.
-
Get
-
these
-
nasty
-
Romans
-
off
-
our
-
back.
-
Now,
-
the
-
apostle
-
knows,
-
and I'm
-
sure you
-
know,
-
we know,
-
that
-
Jesus
-
is the
-
answer
-
to
-
both.
-
He
-
is
-
the
-
logos,
-
the
-
very
-
word
-
that the
-
Greeks
-
use for
-
the
-
primal
-
and
-
pervading
-
rational
-
principle
-
of the
-
cosmos.
-
I mean,
-
think John
-
1.
-
This is
-
why so
-
many
-
Stoics
-
came to
-
Christ.
-
Oh,
-
my
-
goodness,
-
the
-
logos is
-
personal.
-
We
-
never
-
thought
-
of
-
that.
-
Jesus
-
is also,
-
as Isaiah
-
wrote,
-
the arm
-
of the
-
Lord.
-
That
-
is,
-
the
-
acting,
-
saving
-
power of
-
God
-
come into
-
the
-
world.
-
Jesus
-
is both.
-
Oh,
-
wow,
-
there we
-
go.
-
One
-
might have
-
thought,
-
after that
-
analysis and
-
seeing,
-
oh,
-
I see
-
where I
-
can go,
-
you would
-
have thought
-
the apostle
-
would dive
-
right in
-
and show
-
Christ as
-
the fulfillment
-
of both
-
of these
-
longings,
-
wherever
-
they were
-
contextualized.
-
Clear
-
skies,
-
all clear
-
sailing ahead.
-
And yet,
-
if you have the
-
text in front
-
of you,
-
you'll
-
notice the
-
next word
-
in our
-
text is
-
but,
-
but,
-
all right?
-
And the
-
sentence
-
reads,
-
but,
-
we
-
preach
-
Christ
-
crucified,
-
a
-
stumbling
-
block to
-
the Jews
-
and a
-
folly to
-
the Greeks.
-
Verse 23,
-
if you're
-
following.
-
Whoa,
-
whoa,
-
whoa.
-
Is the
-
apostle
-
backing
-
away from
-
his cultural
-
contextualization
-
practice?
-
might appear
-
that way.
-
No,
-
I do
-
not believe
-
so.
-
Notice
-
that the
-
very next
-
word is
-
a further
-
but.
-
Okay?
-
Verse 24,
-
and the
-
sentence
-
reads,
-
but,
-
to those
-
who are
-
called,
-
both Jews
-
and Greeks,
-
Christ,
-
the power
-
of God,
-
and the
-
wisdom of
-
God.
-
Aha!
-
Here again
-
are those
-
resonant
-
categories
-
of this
-
cultural
-
analysis.
-
Do you
-
see that?
-
What's
-
going on?
-
The answer
-
is,
-
Christ
-
is
-
the
-
fulfillment
-
of these
-
cultural
-
longings,
-
but,
-
these
-
cultural
-
aspirations
-
have been
-
warped by
-
sin
-
and twisted
-
into
-
flesh-serving
-
idols.
-
And Paul
-
will
-
lovingly
-
serve
-
his fellows.
-
Remember,
-
I make
-
myself
-
servant
-
to all.
-
He will
-
lovingly
-
serve his
-
fellows
-
by confronting
-
their idols.
-
And confront
-
them
-
he must.
-
They must
-
be confronted
-
for we
-
are in
-
our
-
idols'
-
grip.
-
The reason
-
why the
-
idols have
-
such power
-
in culture
-
is that they
-
are functioning
-
as cultural
-
saviors.
-
gods.
-
But that's
-
a role
-
that they
-
can't
-
fulfill.
-
They are
-
so
-
puissive,
-
so powerful
-
because these
-
cultural
-
godlets,
-
it's a
-
great word
-
of Nietzsche's,
-
these little
-
gods,
-
these seeming
-
gods,
-
these godlets,
-
they are so
-
powerful because
-
they're knock-offs
-
of God's
-
originals.
-
They are,
-
to use a
-
metaphor,
-
they are
-
cracked and
-
broken
-
casts
-
off the
-
true divine
-
power and
-
divine wisdom
-
for which our
-
hearts long.
-
These broken
-
casts need
-
to be
-
subverted
-
for they
-
shall never
-
save us
-
and must
-
be seen
-
within their
-
culture to
-
be impotent
-
imitations
-
and usurpers.
-
These godlets
-
will fail us
-
and they will
-
fail the
-
culture.
-
Sought as
-
saviors,
-
they become
-
our
-
undertakers.
-
To
-
subvert
-
these
-
cultural
-
idols,
-
Paul
-
preaches
-
Christ
-
crucified.
-
Now,
-
how
-
does the
-
cross
-
subvert
-
our
-
cultural
-
idols?
-
It
-
shows
-
that these
-
godlets
-
can never
-
deliver on
-
their
-
promises.
-
God
-
these godlets
-
for all
-
their worldly
-
popularity and
-
acclaim can
-
never bring
-
us to God,
-
can never
-
reconcile us
-
to Him
-
who alone
-
is the
-
source,
-
the substance,
-
and the
-
summit
-
of all of
-
our confused,
-
chaotic,
-
and convulsive
-
longings.
-
God has to
-
come down for
-
us and
-
our salvation.
-
The
-
logos come
-
in the
-
flesh to
-
die in our
-
place.
-
grace.
-
So the
-
cross
-
engenders
-
both
-
humility
-
and hope.
-
The grace
-
of the
-
cross
-
means that
-
no flesh
-
may boast,
-
for Christ
-
has paid
-
the debt.
-
And the
-
cross means
-
that all
-
humbled
-
flesh
-
may hope,
-
for Christ
-
has paid
-
the debt.
-
here,
-
in the
-
cross,
-
is divine
-
power and
-
divine wisdom
-
displayed.
-
Our
-
heart
-
longings
-
that we
-
have
-
desperately
-
and mistakenly
-
enthroned in
-
our culture,
-
these usurpers,
-
these longings
-
springing up
-
from the
-
ineradicable
-
image of
-
God within,
-
are actually
-
fulfilled
-
when brought
-
to Christ,
-
who became
-
to us
-
wisdom,
-
became to
-
us power,
-
and righteousness,
-
and sanctification,
-
etc.
-
And so it
-
is that
-
our longings
-
have,
-
by the
-
gospel,
-
been
-
subversively
-
fulfilled.
-
Subversively
-
fulfilled.
-
It's a
-
useful phrase
-
to kind of
-
capture this
-
idea that
-
Paul has,
-
this method
-
of contextualization.
-
Subversive
-
fulfillment.
-
The gospel
-
contextualized
-
is both
-
the
-
confrontation
-
and
-
contradiction,
-
but finally
-
in Christ,
-
the
-
consummation
-
of our
-
human hopes.
-
Do you see
-
those together?
-
it's so
-
important.
-
Subversive
-
fulfillment.
-
For you
-
historians here,
-
the first
-
use of
-
this term,
-
I'm pretty
-
sure,
-
is of
-
subversive
-
fulfillment,
-
is by the
-
Dutch
-
missiologist
-
Hendrik
-
Kramer
-
in a
-
1939
-
essay
-
called
-
Continuity
-
and
-
Discontinuity
-
at a
-
massive
-
missions
-
conference
-
where he
-
writes,
-
only an
-
attentive
-
study of
-
the Bible
-
can open
-
the eyes
-
to the
-
fact that
-
Christ,
-
the power
-
of God
-
and the
-
wisdom of
-
God,
-
stands in
-
contradiction
-
to the
-
power and
-
wisdom of
-
man.
-
Perhaps,
-
in some
-
respects,
-
it is
-
proper to
-
speak of
-
contradictive
-
or subversive
-
fulfillment.
-
So,
-
that's where
-
it came
-
from.
-
That's just
-
historical
-
interest.
-
So,
-
contextualization
-
requires
-
both
-
connection
-
and
-
confrontation.
-
It must
-
be
-
appealing
-
by cultural
-
resonance,
-
must be
-
appealing to
-
our hearers
-
by cultural
-
resonance,
-
but also
-
appeal to
-
gospel
-
repentance.
-
So,
-
appealing to
-
resonance,
-
but appeal
-
to repentance.
-
When Jesus
-
and his
-
gospel does
-
not bring
-
any sign
-
of contradiction,
-
Luke 2,
-
34,
-
Jesus comes
-
as a sign
-
of contradiction,
-
the culture
-
is simply
-
affirmed and
-
the gospel
-
is domesticated
-
or absorbed
-
into the
-
cultural
-
idolatries.
-
If the
-
new patch
-
does not
-
tear the
-
old cloth,
-
nor the
-
new wine
-
burst the
-
old wineskins,
-
it's not
-
Christ and
-
his gospel.
-
The effect
-
of the
-
attempted
-
fusion
-
is simply
-
syncretism.
-
You see
-
that?
-
Just syncretism.
-
Alternatively,
-
if the
-
gospel is
-
not translated
-
into the
-
cultural
-
vernacular
-
and the
-
idioms
-
of its
-
aspirations
-
and anguishes,
-
it will
-
make no
-
connection.
-
So,
-
like a
-
spacecraft
-
attempting
-
re-entry
-
at an
-
impossible
-
trajectory,
-
it will
-
glance off
-
the cultural
-
atmosphere and
-
make no
-
penetration at
-
all.
-
The gospel
-
will be
-
dismissed
-
as
-
incomprehensible
-
and
-
inapplicable.
-
So,
-
the model
-
the apostle
-
gives
-
to us
-
for our
-
missionary
-
gospel
-
contextualization
-
is vitally
-
balanced.
-
He steers
-
a subtle,
-
discerning,
-
principled
-
course
-
between
-
dual
-
dangers.
-
The
-
scylla
-
of
-
syncretism
-
that fails
-
to confront
-
the culture
-
and the
-
charybdis
-
of irrelevancy
-
that fails
-
to connect
-
to culture.
-
So,
-
may God
-
make us
-
wise and
-
skilled by
-
his spirit
-
in our
-
contextualization,
-
carefully
-
and joyfully
-
imitating
-
the apostle
-
and the
-
one
-
whom he
-
imitates,
-
our very
-
Lord.
-
So,
-
let me,
-
yeah,
-
I'll end
-
there and
-
open it up
-
for any
-
questions.
-
I think
-
we've got
-
a good
-
ten minutes.
-
Yes,
-
Richard,
-
I jump
-
in.
-
So,
-
to begin
-
at the
-
end,
-
since the
-
beginning
-
is harder
-
for me
-
to remember,
-
no doubt.
-
Which do
-
you think
-
in church
-
history
-
has been
-
the greater
-
pitfall?
-
The irrelevance
-
or the
-
syncretism?
-
Right.
-
Oh,
-
my.
-
Well,
-
you know,
-
Luther says,
-
we as
-
Christians,
-
it's like
-
we're a
-
drunk
-
trying to
-
stay on
-
a horse.
-
We seem
-
to just
-
fall off
-
on one
-
side and
-
think,
-
oh,
-
that was
-
terrible,
-
I'm going
-
to lean
-
the other
-
way,
-
and then
-
we,
-
he says,
-
we fall
-
off on the
-
other side,
-
you know,
-
all the time.
-
So interestingly,
-
if you go
-
through church
-
history,
-
that would be
-
another marvelous
-
lesson to just go
-
through and look at
-
all the ways in
-
which it's as if
-
people fall off on
-
one side and
-
think,
-
whoa,
-
we really burned
-
our hand on that,
-
didn't we?
-
and then we go
-
over here and
-
then you go
-
from the frying
-
pan to the fire,
-
frying pan to the
-
fire.
-
So we just seem
-
to careen back
-
and forth.
-
Hopefully it's
-
somewhat,
-
it's somewhat
-
instructional and
-
corrective as we
-
do,
-
but it's really
-
hard to judge.
-
It's not as one
-
as if a big
-
danger,
-
and this is,
-
you know,
-
I use the
-
metaphor of
-
Scylla and
-
Charybdis,
-
and this in
-
Greek mythology,
-
you know,
-
oh,
-
you know,
-
do we,
-
do we,
-
do we pass
-
the,
-
you know,
-
the rocks that
-
will sink our
-
ship for sure,
-
or do we go
-
with a maelstrom
-
and sink down,
-
you know,
-
and be sucked
-
down?
-
They're both
-
equally fatal.
-
Whoa,
-
let's make sure
-
we go right
-
down the middle
-
on this.
-
So,
-
it,
-
it,
-
so,
-
syncretism
-
happens all
-
the time in
-
the history of
-
the church.
-
You can come
-
to the Goths
-
and you can
-
tell them,
-
look,
-
so Boniface,
-
I'll take the,
-
this,
-
this used to be
-
St. Boniface.
-
We have this
-
wonderful stained
-
glass window of
-
Boniface,
-
the first missionary
-
to the Goths,
-
okay,
-
and,
-
and he comes in
-
and he claims,
-
Jesus is more
-
powerful than Thor
-
and Woden
-
and your gods.
-
So he goes to
-
the sacred oak
-
of Donner,
-
thunder and lightning,
-
that represented
-
their god,
-
the shrine to
-
their god.
-
And he goes up
-
to one of these
-
burly Goths
-
and he wrenches
-
the axe from his
-
hand and says,
-
watch this.
-
And he raises it
-
up,
-
about to strike
-
the sacred oak
-
of Donner.
-
All these Goths
-
step way back,
-
sure that their
-
god is going to
-
respond by lightning,
-
his modus.
-
And Boniface
-
hacks that thing
-
and hacks and
-
hacks and there's
-
no lightning.
-
And these Goths
-
think,
-
whoa,
-
maybe Jesus is
-
more powerful
-
than Woden.
-
Wouldn't this
-
be incredibly
-
useful to have
-
on our side?
-
Then we could
-
really clobber
-
our enemies
-
with this kind
-
of power.
-
Now,
-
if you
-
communicate
-
the gospel
-
like that,
-
you just
-
connect
-
the gospel
-
to
-
this
-
fleshly
-
distorted
-
aspiration
-
that they have
-
for power.
-
Is power
-
a good thing?
-
Yes,
-
but as sin
-
distorts it
-
and twists it,
-
if we just
-
connect the gospel
-
up to that,
-
we're never
-
really challenging
-
that fleshly
-
distortion.
-
And the gospel
-
is just being
-
assimilated
-
and it becomes
-
syncretism.
-
See,
-
because every
-
culture
-
is an
-
amalgam
-
of the image
-
of God
-
and the
-
twistedness
-
of sin.
-
So,
-
every sort
-
of cultural
-
feature
-
is going
-
to have
-
some sort
-
of positive
-
imago
-
Dei
-
or image
-
of God
-
aspect
-
to it.
-
These heart
-
longings.
-
Augustine says,
-
the heart
-
is restless
-
until we find
-
a rest in him.
-
The heart
-
stretches
-
for justice,
-
for beauty,
-
for intimacy,
-
all these good
-
things.
-
But there are
-
all these
-
distortions
-
of it
-
through sin.
-
So,
-
what we
-
need to
-
do is
-
we want
-
to connect
-
the gospel
-
to some
-
of those
-
imago Dei,
-
these image
-
of God
-
stirrings
-
and not
-
connect
-
the gospel
-
to the
-
fleshly
-
distortions.
-
That's a
-
historical one,
-
but more
-
recently,
-
there are
-
those
-
who would
-
say,
-
look,
-
what do
-
you really
-
want?
-
Ah,
-
I want
-
a big
-
bank account,
-
I want
-
two cars
-
in my
-
garage,
-
the white
-
picket fence,
-
cute dog,
-
the American
-
life,
-
and lots
-
of golf.
-
Well,
-
you know
-
what?
-
Jesus
-
can do
-
that for
-
you.
-
He can
-
give you
-
your best
-
life now.
-
Well,
-
that's
-
true,
-
he can
-
give you
-
the best
-
life now,
-
but if
-
you don't
-
clarify
-
and challenge
-
the worldly
-
distorted view
-
of their best
-
life now,
-
and just
-
connect up,
-
say,
-
Christ
-
can give
-
you the
-
best life
-
now,
-
what's
-
your best
-
life now?
-
It's the
-
very thing
-
you're
-
thinking.
-
Two cars
-
in the
-
garage,
-
the bank
-
out,
-
the fun
-
dog.
-
That never
-
contradicts
-
or challenges
-
and it
-
becomes
-
syncretism.
-
So,
-
those are
-
some examples
-
of how
-
we have
-
failed in
-
making it
-
just
-
syncretism.
-
We have
-
not
-
challenged.
-
but we
-
can
-
equally,
-
okay,
-
I can,
-
and here's
-
the beautiful
-
thing,
-
Richard,
-
God can
-
use even
-
our
-
paltry,
-
pathetic,
-
misguided,
-
misdirected,
-
mismotivated
-
attempts.
-
Paul says
-
as much in
-
Philippians,
-
he says,
-
hey,
-
some people
-
are preaching
-
Christ just
-
to bring me
-
more agony
-
here.
-
You know
-
what?
-
As long
-
as Christ
-
is preached,
-
I rejoice
-
and God
-
can use
-
these things.
-
But,
-
have you
-
ever seen
-
gospel
-
presentations
-
where
-
it just
-
doesn't seem
-
to connect?
-
Maybe you
-
take a
-
bullhorn
-
and you
-
go on
-
Beinecke
-
Plaza
-
and say,
-
repent for
-
the end
-
is near
-
or have
-
you been
-
washed in
-
the blood
-
of the
-
Nazarene
-
carpenter
-
or whatever
-
it might
-
be.
-
One time
-
I saw
-
on a
-
New York
-
subway,
-
I kid you
-
not,
-
someone,
-
I guess
-
an evangelist
-
or someone
-
who wanted
-
to do,
-
had wrote
-
Jesus saves
-
and somebody
-
had scrawled
-
under it,
-
what?
-
Stamps?
-
Coins?
-
So,
-
it doesn't
-
really
-
connect
-
to the
-
questions
-
they're
-
asking.
-
And in
-
order,
-
you look
-
at gospel
-
tracts,
-
the history
-
of gospel
-
tracts,
-
the good
-
ones
-
actually
-
present
-
Jesus
-
as an
-
answer
-
to a
-
question
-
that the
-
people
-
are asking.
-
sometimes
-
have you
-
there are
-
some tracts
-
that say
-
something like
-
how might
-
you be
-
just
-
before the
-
bar of
-
God?
-
Well,
-
maybe people
-
aren't asking
-
that question.
-
they don't
-
really have
-
any sort
-
of sense
-
of God
-
as judge
-
or as
-
bar.
-
No,
-
that's a
-
place that
-
I kind
-
of like
-
to get
-
out.
-
It just
-
doesn't
-
communicate.
-
So,
-
we always
-
need to
-
translate
-
into some
-
sort of
-
question
-
that is
-
being
-
asked.
-
Christ.
-
Yeah,
-
yeah.
-
Just real
-
quick.
-
Sure.
-
When you're
-
talking about
-
the
-
messianic
-
woes,
-
Christ's
-
sufferings
-
were propitious.
-
Well,
-
propitiatory.
-
Yes,
-
and ours
-
were
-
propagatory.
-
His was
-
atoning,
-
ours
-
merely
-
announcing.
-
Yes?
-
Yes.
-
Right,
-
right.
-
So,
-
one of the
-
things that
-
I think is
-
so important
-
is,
-
it is
-
not a,
-
the
-
gospel,
-
can make,
-
can make
-
its home
-
in any
-
and every
-
culture.
-
So,
-
it's not
-
a matter
-
of saying,
-
hey,
-
you need
-
to change
-
all these
-
cultural
-
trappings
-
and become
-
like this
-
other
-
culture.
-
No,
-
no,
-
no.
-
We want
-
to see
-
the gospel
-
in the
-
soil of
-
another
-
culture
-
and see
-
how it
-
grows out.
-
Now,
-
even though
-
the gospel
-
and its
-
glorious
-
can make
-
its home
-
in every
-
culture,
-
it is
-
never
-
perfectly
-
at home,
-
at home,
-
in any
-
culture.
-
There is
-
always going
-
to be,
-
there's an
-
indigenizing
-
principle,
-
but there's
-
always a
-
pilgrimizing
-
principle.
-
It calls
-
us away
-
from some
-
things because
-
we're ultimately
-
citizens of
-
the kingdom
-
of God.
-
But,
-
our,
-
our gospel
-
identity will be
-
inflected in a
-
glorious,
-
beautiful way
-
by our very
-
culture.
-
culture.
-
So,
-
what the
-
gospel does
-
is it
-
comes in
-
and it
-
gives the
-
possibility
-
of that
-
culture
-
being a
-
more
-
beautiful,
-
wonderful,
-
full expression
-
of all that
-
God had
-
for that
-
particular
-
culture
-
to express
-
the gospel.
-
And it
-
will inflect it
-
in some way.
-
This is what
-
Isaiah talks
-
about,
-
the wealth
-
of the
-
nations
-
coming in
-
and bringing
-
all,
-
all of their
-
glories of
-
their culture.
-
Yeah,
-
the Midianites
-
bring their
-
camels and
-
we might say
-
the Swiss
-
bring their
-
cuckoo clocks
-
and,
-
you know,
-
everybody's got
-
their own
-
cultural contribution
-
that's going to
-
reflect certain
-
things.
-
So,
-
there's not
-
going to be
-
in any way
-
a monotony.
-
It's every
-
tongue,
-
tribe,
-
and nation.
-
So,
-
there will be
-
these cultural
-
expressions,
-
but,
-
but every
-
turning away
-
from something
-
in their
-
culture that
-
the gospel
-
calls them to
-
is actually
-
a purification
-
of that
-
very beauty
-
of that
-
culture.
-
It's taking
-
away the
-
things that
-
are distorting,
-
that are
-
disfiguring of
-
that culture.
-
So,
-
no,
-
no,
-
no,
-
we want you
-
to come
-
into the
-
true glorious
-
self that
-
only the
-
gospel and
-
your right
-
restored
-
relationship to
-
God can
-
really bring
-
out and
-
fuel.
-
So,
-
it's not an
-
utter
-
repudiation,
-
it's a
-
reclamation
-
of your
-
culture.
-
So,
-
that would
-
be some
-
of the
-
things that
-
I would
-
emphasize.
-
Yes,
-
yes,
-
Susan.
-
Thank you so
-
much for
-
interviewing
-
today.
-
What are
-
some ways
-
in the
-
current
-
cultural
-
context
-
that you
-
see the
-
church
-
can bring
-
the gospel
-
and appeal
-
the gospel
-
to it?
-
Yeah,
-
well,
-
I think
-
we go
-
and we
-
try to
-
figure out
-
what are
-
the questions
-
that they
-
have?
-
What are
-
the things
-
that consume
-
them?
-
And,
-
you know,
-
maybe it's
-
we want
-
to have
-
freedom.
-
Freedom is
-
such a big
-
thing.
-
I never
-
want to
-
restrict my
-
choices.
-
I only want
-
to have as
-
many choices
-
as I can.
-
I don't
-
want to
-
commit myself
-
to anything.
-
And yet,
-
at the same
-
time,
-
I want to
-
have a sense
-
of community.
-
I have a
-
deep longing
-
to belong.
-
So,
-
I want my
-
freedom,
-
but I want
-
belonging.
-
Ho,
-
cross-purpose.
-
How does
-
that happen?
-
So,
-
we go in
-
and we
-
take up
-
questions
-
that they
-
naturally
-
have.
-
How's that
-
going for
-
you?
-
Listen to
-
where they
-
see,
-
and then we
-
can show
-
how the
-
gospel is
-
good news
-
at the
-
very point
-
of their
-
greatest
-
concerns.
-
So,
-
that's why.
-
Oh,
-
I'm realizing
-
we probably
-
need to
-
leave.
-
But,
-
thank you,
-
team.
-
Next week,
-
this will
-
continue.
-
I think,
-
I didn't do
-
a whole lot
-
of applications
-
except at the
-
end.
-
And,
-
we're going
-
to continue
-
for a few
-
more weeks.
-
Matt,
-
Matt will,
-
I believe.
-
Thank you.